Page 131 of I Was Always Yours (RCA: Royal Crown Academy)

“I told you I got you another present but that this one would be mostly for me, didn’t I?”

She nods unhurriedly, feigning agreement, before she scrambles to her feet and darts for the door.

I catch her around the waist and throw her back face down onto the bed, pinning her legs beneath mine as I press a hand into the middle of her back.

I laugh demonically as I bring my lips to her ear. “Running away from me only makes me want to fuck you even harder. Or did you forget how I used to chase you down?”

“Phoenix,” she starts, but I clasp my hand over her mouth and silence her.

“Shh,” I warn against her ear. “The more you resist, the harder I get. If you’re not careful, I’ll fuck your ass tonight instead of just plugging it like I originally planned.”

She stiffens when I drop the lube and plug she’d seen in my hands onto the bed next to her.

“Stay.” I command, releasing her.

She does as I ask, staying still as I get to my feet. I part her legs wide and then kneel between them as I run my hands over her ass, kneading the soft flesh with my greedy hands.

Spreading her cheeks open for me, I run my tongue once more down her crack until I bite her clit. She jerks and shrieks but lays back into position once she recovers.

Popping open the cap on the lube bottle, I pour some directly onto her pink asshole, enjoying the way it winks in response.

I swirl my index around her whorl a couple of times and then press in, pushing my finger in to the hilt with barely any resistance.

I feel her wince, feel her back muscles tighten as she gets accustomed to the intrusion, but the ease with which my finger penetrates her reveals how much she likes it.

“I wish you could see the way your ass just swallowed my finger,” I tell her suggestively, my voice hoarse with arousal. “Are you just pretending to fight me on this, hmm?”

“No…ah!” She yelps when I pull out completely and push back in more roughly. “No.”

“Are you sure? Because your ass is opening up like a little slut and basically begging my finger to fuck it.”

“You’re l-lying.” She says, but she’s panting.

“Am I?” I taunt. “I think my finger is feeling pretty lonely.”

I pull out again, but this time I push back in with two fingers. It’s a tight fit and I don’t get past the first knuckle before I’m met with resistance.

Grabbing the lube with my free hand, I squirt some more on my fingers and directly onto her hole.I press back with both fingers, pushing past her ring of muscles until I breach her ass.

“Fuck,” she moans, her voice trembling as her forehead drops to the mattress.

“Relax.” I order.

“Easy for you to say,” she chirps back, her words muffled against the sheets. She squeals when I shove my fingers to the hilt inside her, bottoming out until there’s nowhere left to go.

“This is happening whether you relax or not. Only one of those will make it enjoyable for you.” I collect her hair into a makeshift ponytail before tugging on it, bringing her chest to chest with me as my fingers stay in her ass. “Then again, you like the pain, don’t you?”

I scissor my fingers inside her and she cries out at the agonizing stretch. I don’t give her an opportunity to answer before I start pounding into her.

“I can’t believe how tight this hole is.” I praise, “What’s my cock going to feel like in this ass? Will it even fit?” I bite her lobe, delivering deviant words directly against her ear. “I can’t wait to watch you struggle to take every inch of me. You’ll scream for me, won’t you?”

Shivers wrack her entire body as her mouth parts on a silent cry. I know my dirty words get to her as much as my fingers do.

Her hand snakes to her front and ghosts over her clit before I slap it away.

“You’ll come from my fingers in your ass or you won’t come at all.” I warn, releasing her.

The top half of her body falls back onto the mattress as I ramp up the speed of my intrusion. Her toes curl and her legs pulse and I throw her a pillow.

---