Page 9 of Between Dusk and Dawn

There were two ways I could approach this situation. I could slow down and take the ten minutes I knew it would take Cagento get her bag and come upstairs. Then spray Maddy’s face with my cum so it would be covered when she walked in.

It would cause a huge scene and put Maddy in her place, punish both of us for this indiscretion, and ultimately fuck up my grand plan in my life. The guys at the Alpha house would lose any respect they had for me since I was no longer dating the most popular girl on campus and screwed her over. I would lose my father’s respect, because the gossip train from Isles to Dansport is deep.

But I could be with Maddy. I could claim her as mine and flaunt her around, but there would be no one to flaunt her to.

The logical decision would’ve been to push her off me as soon as I marked her. She would say nothing because she was still too engrossed in wanting to fit in. I would get to continue dating Cagen. She’d carry this act on her shoulders as embarrassment. The moment I pushed her away, she’d hate me.

However, there was a bigger plan in action, and I needed to think with my brain and not my cock. So I thrust a few more times before pulling out.

"Lean back. Push your tits together," I demanded, pulling her straps of her dress down and aiming into the center of her plush tits. She obliged as I used my hand to pump my orgasm out, exploding onto her chest.

"You like that, don’t you?" she murmured through a raspy, sensual tone.

"Fuck," I groaned, draining every ounce as quick as possible.

I adjusted my cock, lifted my jeans, and shoved it inside. "Get up," I commanded.

We both looked toward the jingling door handle. I was grateful for my forward thinking when locking the deadbolt.

"Cagen." Maddy jumped up, adjusting her dress.

"The deadbolt is locked," I said, shifting my dick in my pants so Cagen wouldn’t see how hard I was.

Maddy reached for me, and I grabbed her wrists, stopping her.

"One day, Muse, you will be mine." I pushed away a rogue lock of hair from her forehead.

"Go in the shower. Wash up and finish yourself off with that thick veiny dildo you like to suction to the walls, Madison."

She stilled, shock etched into every feature of her face. "How do you—" The corners of my lips twisted into a smirk.

"Remember? Your worst nightmare."

After a moment, she whimpered out, "M-my name is Maddy."

I released a low, ominous chuckle. "No, it was Maddy. That's the facade you hide behind. But with me, you are Madison. I've seen the depths within you; I know the real you."

"You don’t know me at all. I only sucked you off."

"Was that all it was to you?" I asked, inching closer to her.

"Yes."

My tone softened. "You wear the face skillfully, but you don't need to hide from me, Muse."

The knocking intensified as Cagen's shouts pierced the air.

"Aren't you scared I'll tell her?" she whispered.

"No, you'd never."

"How do you know?"

You want to protect me, too.I wanted to tell her that. I needed her to know we offered it to each other, but I kept that secret to myself.

Lifting my hands to her face, I lowered to where my lips hovered just above hers. Every fiber of my being craved to kiss her, but I understood that once I did, nothing else would ever taste as sweet.

"Because I just do, Madison." My gaze shifted to the door. "Go," I commanded.

---