Page 44 of My Ex-Best Friends

We heard Logan’s door shut upstairs and then looked at each other. Colt surprised me with a smirk before shaking his head. Logan and I waited for him to spit it out.

“I should’ve hunted her ass down ten years ago.” He looked up, as if he could see her, and cracked his neck. “She needs us. Probably has always needed us.”

I nodded. “She’s here now.”

Logan blew out a harsh breath. “I’m serious. She’s not leaving us again.”

“Fuck it. I’m down with kidnapping her little ass if she tries to pull something stupid again.” Colt grinned suddenly. “Now. What the fuck are we doing?”

“What do you mean? I thought we’d just established that.” I frowned. “Were you not-”

“I mean, Noah, that we’ve done this once before and you just promised to have her coming harder and more than ever. I’m not trying to get up there and stumble over the two of you.”

“It was easy the first time.” I thought so, anyway. “Neither of you touch my dick and we’ll be good.”

Logan shoved me. “Idiot.”

“Think she’s already naked and waiting?” Colt ran his hand through his hair, anxious to go up.

Logan yanked his shirt over his head. “She’s mine first.”

I didn’t love it but I also knew that he was feeling unhappy about being the only one of us who hadn’t fucked her since she’d been back. Colt nodded so I followed suit.

“She fucking loved having us watch the first time. She wouldn’t have ever said it back then, but I remember. It was just me and her because you two were going to wait outside of the clubhouse. She was nervous.” Colt rubbed his face. “She was wet and I had my fingers in her, trying to make sure I wouldn’t hurt her when I took her virginity.”

“Worst coin toss loss in my fucking life, by the way.” I growled.

“It started pouring rain so we came inside.” Logan shook his head. “She was stretched out for you, naked in just the light of that one candle. It smelled like fucking cupcakes and I get hard everytime I smell cupcakes now.”

“She froze when you two came in but my fingers were inside her. She couldn’t hide her reaction from me. She got wetter. She clenched down on my fingers and I almost came in my fucking pants. She was so wet when I finally fucked her.” Colt looked at us. “Logan fucks her first. Noah and I’ll watch. And then all bets are off. I need her mouth on me while one of you fucks her.”

I shifted myself in my pants so I wasn’t pointing my dick at them. “Why is that so fucking hot? Watching one of you take her while I filled her mouth the first time still wakes me up in a sweat.”

“No more questions.” Logan pushed us both. “Are we really down here, reminiscing, when our woman is naked and spread out upstairs?”

“Our woman.” Colt shoved me and then Logan. “Jesus. What a bunch of losers. Let’s go.”

We sounded like a herd of buffalo coming up the stairs but when we got to Logan’s room and opened the door, somehow, our woman hadn’t heard a thing. She was naked, her beautiful body exposed, but she was sleeping so hard that she was lightly snoring. She’d curled up on her side with Logan’s pillow and she was out.

We stopped and watched her for a few seconds before Logan went over and pulled his blanket over her. When he bent to kiss her forehead, she stirred.

“Goodnight, little bunny.”

She lifted her arms for him. “Don’t leave.”

“I won’t.” He kicked off his pants and walked over to us. “Raincheck?”

I smiled at the pout on her face as she searched for him. “Go. We’ll finish this later.”

Colt nodded and patted his shoulder. “I’m just going to go take a cold shower and think of all the ways I’m going to fuck with you to get you back.”

Logan rolled his eyes and closed his door in our faces. Through the door, we both heard him mutter. “Okay. Now to cuddle a naked little bunny without coming in my boxers.”

Colt snorted and we both moved down the hall towards our rooms. He stopped outside of my door and looked at me. “You going to be alright?”

I made a face. “You offering to come in and suck my dick? Yeah, I’m going to be alright.”

He punched me. “No, fuckhead. Go suck your own dick. I meant with all of this. Logan and I, we don’t have a family to worry about. Are you ready to get calls from your parents?”

---