Page 4 of Calling Her Bluff

Eyes big, indignation written across her features, all she could do was watch as he shaved her pussy clean. When all the hair was gone, he wiped her down with the washcloth and sat back to admire her newly bald pussy. Perfectly pink, her clit was poking out from between her little pussy lips.

“Even more beautiful than before.”

He smiled at the furious expression on her face. Half of her anger was at herself for feeling happy he’d called her beautiful.

Putting aside the instruments of her humiliation, he opened the massage oil and squirted some into his palms. Deftly, he massaged her breasts, kneading them between his fingers, enjoying having the heavy globes in his hands and making them gleam slickly in the lamplight. Allison arched her back. Todd’s hands felt incredible on her body—she liked this part. He was plucking her nipples, making her gasp and grind her hips into the bed. Her nipples had always been one of the most sensitive parts of her body. The massage oil was starting to heat up with the friction and giving off the distinct smell of strawberries. Her suspicion it was flavored was confirmed when he lowered his head to her nipple, licking and sucking it.

Oooh, that felt even better. His tongue flicked the tip of her nipple as he sucked it into his mouth, his free hand still playing with her other breast, pinching the tender nubbin. Her chest was starting to feel hot and even more sensitive as the massage oil really began to work its magic. When he lowered his hand to her pussy, she realized she was dripping, wetter than she’d ever been before in her life.

His fingers rubbed massage oil around her pussy lips, making them tingle warmly. She groaned and pushed against his finger as it slowly began to move into her. It felt slick and thick, and he added another finger, stretching her out. Then he lifted his head from her nipple, and she moaned and wriggled, wanting his mouth back on her.

Smiling smugly, he slipped off the bed and disrobed. Allison couldn’t do anything but stare. He was huge, about seven inches long, which wasn’t the longest she’d ever seen, but he was definitely the thickest. The massively wide dick bobbed its pinkish head at her, a fat stick hanging off his body, pulled down by its own weight. This was going to hurt. Allison found herself struggling uselessly again.

Laughing at her reaction, Todd fisted his cock and got onto the bed, straddling her stomach. She let out a huge breath of air in relief, he wasn’t going to stick it inside of her yet. Maybe he would take the gag out and be content with a blow job.

He pushed her breasts together, creating a deep cleavage with the large globes and began pushing his dick back and forth between her breasts, aided by the massage oil. Allison had heard of “titty-fucking,” but she’d never thought anyone would actually do it or enjoy it as much as Todd seemed to be.

Todd was enjoying his power over her more than anything else, along with the slick glide of his cock against her skin, the softness of her breasts in his hands, and the quickly changing expressions on her face. Looking down at her face, he could see the conflicted desire there. Allison was just as wild as she’d said, she just needed someone to help release that side of herself.

Releasing her breasts, he enjoyed watching them bounce back into place as he grabbed the vibrator. It was pretty obvious she was completely disgusted by the idea that it had been another girl’s, and her humiliated disgust was a turn on in some way. Knowing she was his to do with as he pleased, knowing he was going to ensure she enjoyed this and broaden her horizons was incredibly arousing. Turning the toy on low, he began running it up and down her pussy lips, pressing it firmly against her clit, then pulling it away.

He had an idea. Turning the vibrator off, he put it aside for the moment. Untying both of her feet—tucking one under each arm so she couldn’t kick—he tied each leg to opposite bedposts on the headboard, so they were higher than her arms, and she was bent nearly double. Now, there was complete access to her pussy and ass, and the camera would get a much better view.

Allison’s new position wasn’t the most comfortable, but she couldn’t deny being restrained was just flat out doing it for her. She was incredibly horny and almost didn’t care anymore that the vibrator had been someone else’s first. This had to be the kinkiest way to lose her virginity. Now that she’d really accepted it, she found freedom in her bondage and lack of choices. Todd’s tongue came down to lick around her pussy lips, sucking on her clit and teasing, kissing her inner thighs. She tried to push back, wanting more of the lovely sensation of his mouth on her most sensitive areas, but the new position he’d put her in made it almost impossible for her to move.

The heat between her legs was getting too heavy for her to ignore. She was panting and trying to move with the vibrator now, enjoying the moments when he licked and sucked her clit. There was nothing going on in her head except the thought of her own orgasm.

There was pressure on a place she had never been touched before, and she immediately tried to scream through her gag.

Noooo!

That wasdirty! Dirty and wrong and gross… but the finger pushed relentlessly forward. Squeezing her muscles together did nothing except make him chuckle as the invading digit burrowed deeper. She winced as he wiggled his finger around in her asshole, causing her to clench spasmodically at the sensations. Thoughts of orgasm were dismissed—she wanted out now! Her ass was not part of a deal with ANY man! She’d been excited about losing her virginity to Todd, but this was too much!

She relaxed as he seemed to get her drift and pulled the finger from her ass. The bastard grinned at her as he began to push two fingers into her tight hole, causing her to wave her hips frantically—as much as she could, anyway. Straining, breath heaving in her chest, she screamed her frustration into the gag. It hurt, although not as much as she’d expected. His fingers spread her open in a way she’d never experienced, her tight hole aching with discomfort. Bearing down on them only made it hurt more as her sphincter muscles stretched and clenched.

Finally, his fingers were all the way inside. She mewled as her body slowly adjusted to its new dimensions. Todd watched her face as he began moving his fingers back and forth, mimicking sex in her asshole and causing her to wriggle at the strange new sensations. Slowly, it began to stop hurting, stop feeling quite so uncomfortable—at least physically. Mentally she was going crazy. Anal sex had never been on her menu. Good girls didn’tdothat. It was perverted, wrong—forbidden.

So, why was it starting to feel so good?

Fear returned when Todd pulled his fingers out and positioned himself between her legs. The buzzing pleasure of the vibrator did nothing to lessen her anxiety, although it seemed to heighten her anticipation. The wide head of his cock pressed against her crinkled hole, spreading open her virgin anus much wider than his fingers had. The discomfort was just shy of painful, and the actual spreading sensation was intense. She could feel herself stretching around the tip of the head, stretching and stretching and stretching… There was no way he was going to get that monster in her ass. He was going to tear her apart. As she began to panic and scream behind the gag in fear and pain, she inadvertently relaxed her ass muscles, and the head of his dick finally managed to pop past the tight ring of muscle that had been fighting it. Allison’s eyes bulged.

Todd stopped for a moment, running his hands up and down her smooth legs as he let her adjust to the proportions of his cock, to savor the expression on her face. Thoughtfully, he also turned up the vibrator another notch, which would give her more pleasure to help with this discomfort. She was so wonderfully, exquisitely tight. Her body wriggled, trying to adjust rather than protest, now that he was inside, which was incredibly hot.

Leaning forward a bit, he slid himself a little deeper into her ass, causing her to grimace. Reaching forward, he began to play with her nipples. As the vibrator in her pussy and his nimble fingers on her nipples and breasts began to have their effect, she began moving her hips again. He pulled his dick back a bit before pushing more in. With her grimacing and groaning, he slowly worked his dick in and out of her ass, pushing a little more with every stroke. The vibrator moved inside of her, bumped by his body with every thrust.

Allison was beginning to work her way back to an orgasm. The sensations in her ass hurt, but the pain was lessening, and even seemed to be adding to the experience. She’d never felt so full in her life as if every crevice was stretched and overflowing with cock, both real and plastic. With the buzzing vibration in her pussy and the erotic stretch of her ass, the slick glide of Todd’s cock moving back and forth over newly awakened nerves, her body was taking over again and pushing her mental and emotional objections aside.

As Todd hit bottom, he turned up the vibrator another notch and moved in and out of her stretched, deflowered, perfect ass. He could feel the vibrations through the thin membrane between her pussy and anal tract. Her ass was so incredibly tight, he was having a hard time not cumming, but he wanted to draw this out, but most of all, he wanted her cumming on camera while he plundered her virgin ass. As he moved in and out of her tight grip, he made sure his groin hit the bottom of the vibrator every time he filled her, causing it to move within her as well. Noticing the effect playing with her breasts had, he began pulling on her nipples, twisting them slightly with every stroke.

The combination of pain and pleasure was new to Allison, but her body reveled in it. She felt full, completed as if everything was finally right where it should be with her body. The biggest orgasm of her life was building up inside of her. Eyes half-closed, she was moaning and rocking her body, completely oblivious when Todd unwound the scarf from around her head, removing the gag. All of her focus was on the incredible sensations sweeping through her. He was moving harder and faster in her ass, giving her a ride, pulling harshly on her nipples. She could feel herself climbing higher and higher, getting ready for the great fall.

When Todd felt like he couldn’t hold off his own orgasm any longer, he turned the vibrator up to full blast, grabbed her nipples and pinched down hard, pulling them away from her body and using the leverage to slam his dick into her ass.

Allison arched her back and let out a wildly sensual scream, not even realizing she could be heard.

“Oh, Todd!”

Her ass clenched hard around him, spasming as her body began to shake.

---