Page 20 of Calling Her Bluff

At that point, Chad got upset and had to be talked out of having a serious “conversation” with Todd. Fortunately, Diana was on Allison’s side that it was her choice whether to do anything. She also understood the erotic appeal of being blackmailed, especially since it was something Allison had confessed to Todd.

“He’s always pushing me and making me do things I secretly enjoy but would be too scared to do otherwise,” Allison said. “Last night was…” She blushed and looked away from Chad. “It was incredibly hot to be with two men. Even if you might not have been who I would have chosen if he’d asked, that just makes it even more exciting in a lot of ways.”

Chad looked unconvinced but willing to take her word for it. Diana looked frankly envious about the two men part.

“If he ever makes you do anything youreallydon’t want to do, you’ll tell me, right?” he asked. Chad so concerned with her well-being actually touched, Allison even if it wasn’t necessary.

“Yes, of course,” she reassured him, bemused. “But I don’t think he will. It’s… it’s a game we’re playing. If I told him no and stuck to it, I think he’d hand over the tapes immediately, no problem. But I always cave because ultimately, that’s what I really want.” She blushed, knowing how true her words were and a little ashamed at admitting them, but it also felt really good to verbalize it. Explaining it to Diana and Chad was making it easier for her to face it herself.

“But he’s blackmailing you, so how do you know he’d give in?” Chad asked, rolling his eyes at her naivety.

Allison blushed again. “Well, he asked me about the things I wanted him to make me do.” Once she admitted that, nothing would satisfy Diana until she told them about Todd finding her in the library and fingering her while he asked about her fantasies.

Although Chad had noticed Todd hadn’t seemed particularly eager to share Allison, he didn’t tell her that. After all, he might not have been reading his frat brother’s emotions correctly, and just in case, he didn’t want Allison to get hurt. It didn’t even occur to him how sleeping with her had so obviously changed their relationship. His fantasy fulfilled, he found himself protective of her.

* * *

By the time Allison left her Aunt Linda’s house, with Diana’s number in her cell phone and a promise they would get together to hang out soon, she was feeling much better. Talking to other people about what was going on had been a relief. Diana’s enthusiastic support for the fulfillment of her fantasies, rather than horrified condemnation, made Allison feel less like she was deranged or perverted. Chad’s desire to protect her from Todd’s blackmailing had been rather cute, and in turn, made her feel protective of her experiences with Todd.

It had also made her face the fact she was truly enjoying the games and hoops Todd was putting her through. She didn’t want him to stop. In fact, she wasn’t sure she ever wanted him to stop. Friday nights were becoming more about pleasing him and pushing her boundaries than they were about getting the tapes back. Destroying the video evidence was satisfying, but now it seemed like a silly tag end to her getting what she wanted.

Could there ever really be anything between them? Pulling into the gated driveway of her parent’s house—more like a mansion—with its exquisitely cared-for front lawn and sculptured gardens and comparing it to Todd’s apartment was disheartening, driving home the differences between how they lived. At one point, she would have looked down on his apartment. Now, it was starting to feel more comfortable and cozy than the foreboding structure of her own childhood home.

* * *

On Monday, Allison thought about calling Todd, but what would she say? ‘Hey, what’s up?’ She would feel like a complete idiot. No, no, she couldn’t do that. By Tuesday, she had actually gotten her phone out and sat staring at his name in her contact list for about ten minutes before she put it back in her purse and went out the door to the sex store she’d found when she was bought her thigh-highs.

It didn’t take long to find exactly what she wanted, a toy she’d spotted the last time she’d been there but hadn’t been brave enough to get. Tucking the box into her purse after paying for it, she hurried home and up to her room, feeling incredibly naughty.

She was so excited, she immediately locked the door and stripped down. Just thinking about the things Todd had done with her, wondering what would come next had her worked up. He consumed her fantasy life, and all she thought about was what it would be like to truly be his. She’d come to realize she liked the fight with him, liked resisting a little, and having him leverage her into more hedonism. Although she wanted it, it was hard for her to admit. She was only able to really let loose and enjoy herself once Todd exerted his dominance and had taken away her choices.

How odd that not having any choices made her feel so free.

Slipping her vibe into her pussy, set on low, she moaned as the teasing sensation flowed through her. She stripped off the packaging from her new toy, a five-inches long and one-inch in diameter anal probe that was heavily ribbed. Smearing lubricant over its ridged surface, she wondered how it would feel to have it moving in and out of her tight hole while her vibrator buzzed inside her pussy. Would it be as erotic as having two men inside of her? Probably not, but this would be the closest she could get at home.

Planting her feet on the mattress, she thrust her hips upward, sliding her feet farther apart and bending her knees even more to get the perfect angle to push the head of the probe into her asshole as she pushed the vibrator deep into her pussy. Oh… fuck… the bumps on the probe, passing through the tight ring of her anus was incredible… indescribable…

Although it was hard to push both toys in and out of, she persevered. Allison thought about Todd’s mastery over her body, his dark, commanding eyes, the way his skin rasped against hers, his wide cock stretching her open. With a grunt of frustration for her inability to satisfyingly fuck herself in both holes, she pulled the length of the probe out of her ass and almost screamed as the sensation jolted her straight into orgasm. Her pussy clenched and spasmed around the vibrator as she writhed in ecstasy, her ass clenching at its sudden emptiness and the rippling sensation the removal of the probe had caused.

Her climax was fulfilling physically, but she still found her thoughts turning to Todd. For the first time in her life, she felt insecure about a guy. Did he have any feelings for her, or was this just an exciting fuck? Did he enjoy her or his power over her… or both?

* * *

On Wednesday, a new email from Todd finally arrived. Allison’s anticipation seeing it in her inbox was almost disturbing.

Princess,

I am tired of having to reiterate that I am in charge of our dates, and you are getting nothing more than you asked for. You seemed to enjoy the spanking you got last week. I hope you stay in that frame of mind. This Friday, a friend will drop off a package after your parents leave for work. Several items will be in the package, with instructions for the use of each one. The instructions must be followed exactly. Other than what’s in the box, all you will wear is the coat from last week. Keep stretching out your ass. Be at my house at 5pm. Do not be late.

Your Lord and Master

Allison bit her lip. Looking at his signature for this week’s email gave her the shivers, and her nipples hardened. It was as if he knew she pushed him to get a response. The spanking he’d given her had been shockingly arousing, as much as being pushed up against the wall and held there.

Either Todd was very good at reading her body language and knowing exactly what she wanted, or their desires were very similar.

* * *

Although Allison spent almost her entire Thursday afternoon hanging around the library until she had to go home or be late for a family dinner, there was no sign of Todd. She’d hoped he might show up and give her an excuse to see him before Friday, but he was nowhere to be seen. In fact, he hadn’t been outside the gym when she’d walked by earlier, either.

---