Page 17 of Calling Her Bluff

Finally, her body began the descent from the incredible high. She twitched as Chad tenderly licked her over-sensitized pussy. Gentle, feathery light strokes of Todd’s fingers on her breasts soothed the sore flesh, and Chad slowly withdrew his fingers from her holes, still licking as he cleaned the traces of her orgasm from her pussy. Allison humped her hips a few more times before letting her hands fall away from the top of Chad’s head, feeling drained.

As Chad pulled away from her pussy, Todd pushed her unresisting body up and away from his. Too tired to move of her own, Allison allowed the men to position her on her hands and knees. Barely able to hold herself up on her forearms, Allison lowered her mouth to Todd’s very hard cock and stretched her jaw around the familiar thick meat. Behind her, Chad rubbed the head of his dick up and down her wet slit.

She shuddered, knowing this was the point of no return, but she couldn’t deny having two men attending to her turned her on, and she was attracted to the man behind her—the one she’d always looked down on. Maybe the resentment of her attraction to someone she’d considered unworthy had been why she’d teased him so hard, the same way she had Todd.

Chad’s cock nudged its way inside her pussy. He groaned as the hot, wet hole gripped his shaft tightly. Reaching around her body, he grabbed her hanging tits and began pushing his dick in and out of her, using her breasts to leverage his thrusts, slamming his body into her sore ass. Allison moaned around Todd’s cock as Chad became the second man to ever enter her pussy. After having just had an intense orgasm, her pussy was sensitive and ready to respond. She could feel her heat coil and build again as he pumped into her from behind, his manipulation of her breasts and nipples only increasing the flow of adrenaline and hot need.

Todd watched as Allison’s face reflected her enjoyment. He loved to push boundary after boundary, exploring her limits. He had a lot of different ideas for their dates and couldn’t wait to see how she reacted to each one. Admittedly, he hadn’t realized she would balk so hard at this one. After all, Chad was one of the most lusted after guys in the frat. He’d figured Allison teased him because she’d been sexually attracted to him. Although he’d been a part of sharing other women sexually with frat brothers, he wouldn’t have shared Allison if she hadn’t truly been interested in it. Chad’s identity had been the only thing that made her hesitant, and once he’d established he wasn’t going to change his mind, she’d fallen in line.

She really did want to try everything.

A threesome could be incredibly pleasurable, but he’d been surprised how jealous he’d felt to share her attention with someone else. Maybe that was why he’d chosen Chad. No real threat from the other man. Not he should care about that, anyway. Allison wasn’t really his. He’d started this because he was attracted to her, and she challenged him. They had great sexual chemistry, but he hadn’t expected to enjoy her company so much. He also didn’t expect her to want to continue seeing him once she had all the tapes back.

Realizing his thoughts were getting away from him, Todd focused on the gripping suction of Allison’s lips around his cock. Taking bunches of her soft hair, he pulled it into a ponytail close to her head, using it to leverage her mouth on and off of his cock, watching the lust rising in her eyes as she blew him.

Allison could sense him smiling down on her in pleasure, and to her amazement, she felt a rush of accomplishment he was pleased with her. But she couldn’t focus solely on him. Chad was really slamming into her from behind, grinding his groin against the swell of her ass, digging his dick in as deep as he could force it. He was tugging on her nipples as if he was milking a cow. She was having trouble focusing on Todd’s cock as Chad’s movements became wilder, more passionate, less controlled.

She moaned around Todd’s cock, her pussy clamping down on Chad as she began to cum again, her sensitive nipples sending floods of sensation as Chad pulled and squeezed them, sending her over the edge.

The pulsing in her pussy and the realization he’d made the stuck-up tease cum for a second time sent Chad soaring. Crushing her breasts in his palms, he rammed into her, groaning as he finally pumped jet after jet of thick cum into Allison’s spasming pussy, fulfilling a fantasy he’d had for years.

The rush of orgasm had nearly undone her, but as Chad let his dick fall from her body, she didn’t stop sucking Todd until he put one finger under her chin and lifted her head.

“Clean him.” Todd nodded at Chad. She turned, and trying not to think about what she was doing, she licked the juices off Chad’s thighs and balls—tasting herself and him. Gulping down her reluctance, she licked his dick, opening her mouth to let the flaccid member slip in while she sucked away the remains of their sex. Feeling him hardening in her mouth, she finished as quickly as she could and pulled away, not sure if she felt up to sucking him off. Giving him a blow job was more humiliating than allowing him to have sex with her, probably because it would require her active involvement.

“Good girl.”

Grateful for the distraction, Allison turned back to Todd, who smiled at her. Hearing him call her a good girl sent a flash of pure emotional pleasure through her. Pulling her toward him, he lowered his mouth to her raw nipples and gently sucked the pink nubs. Moaning, she ran her hands over his shoulders, enjoying the gentle touch on her breasts. Her pussy started to perk up again, interested and aroused, swollen from use.

Todd laid back, sliding beneath her, so he was flat on his back, his hands on her hips as he guided her into position over his wide cock. She had to be on the tail end of completely exhausted, but she still did what he wanted—better, she was starting to do it without being told to.

Allison winced as his dick stretched her pussy. It was sensitive from use, battered from Chad’s forceful fucking, but she wanted Todd inside her. Gasping and whimpering, she slowly worked her way down until she was completely impaled on the thick shaft. Taking a moment to breathe deeply and adjust, she began moving up and down on him, her inner muscles working as she rode him. Todd reached up and pulled her head down for a kiss, tweaking her nipples with his fingers as his tongue slid into her mouth. Looking past her head, he winked at Chad, who was fully hard again, lubed up, and waiting.

She screamed into Todd’s mouth, her eyes flying wide open as she felt Chad’s hands grip her waist, the head of his cock nudging against her ass. While she had imagined this as a possibility, she wasn’t ready for it yet. Surely, they were too big to both fit inside of her at the same time. Only Todd’s strong hold on her neck and back kept her in position as she wriggled between them, her anus burning as Chad forced more and more of his cock past the tightly gripping entrance.

Her ass was tight and hot, and he could feel Todd’s thick shaft rubbing against his in Allison’s pussy. When Todd had suggested double penetration, Chad got hard just thinking about it. The reality was even better as her frantic body clenched even tighter around his dick. It was heaven as he sank in, balls deep, and Todd finally released Allison from the kiss.

“Oh, God… I can’t… it doesn’t fit, take it out… it’s too much…”

“Shh,” Todd murmured soothingly. He and Chad held still, letting her adjust to the shocking invasion. “It will only take a minute, then it will feel really good, I promise. I’m going to take care of you, Princess. Just relax, we’re going to make you feel so good…”

The murmured comfort worked, and her body unwound, allowing Chad to ease his way out, then slowly sink back in. She moaned, and the two men took that as their cue, moving with slow, steady thrusts, alternating with their twin poles. As Chad pulled away, Todd thrust upward and filled her from below, and as Todd’s hands pushed her up off him, Chad filled her from behind. Wedged between their hard bodies, Allison burned with the fullness, the shocking eroticism of being completely filled.

As her moans turned more sensual, her body beginning to move between them, they picked up their pace, fucking her harder and faster. Everything burned and flared as they thrust, jolting and bouncing inside of her body. She writhed between them, clutching at Todd as her anchor in the overwhelming rush, the crashing sensations that threatened to rip her mind away. The freedom and triumph she felt at this wanton degradation increased her moans and her sharp cries as her body lifted and fell, filled and emptied.

The men enjoyed her submission to the situation, the added tightness and friction to her clutching holes, and the telling cries of pleasure that fell from her lips. Even though Todd hadn’t particularly wanted to share her, he was glad to give her the experience, enjoying the radiant shock on her face as the ecstasy built up inside of her. She was a walking wet-dream, bucking between them.

Even though Chad had already cum once, being in Allison’s tight ass was more than he could take. Having the tease taking him in her forbidden hole was something he’d never dared fantasize about, and the experience was one he knew he’d masturbate to later. Tonight was worth everything she’d ever put him through.

Her pussy and ass burning with intense heat, rippling around the cocks plundering her body, Allison realized she was on her way to another orgasm, and she began to panic. After so many orgasms, her tender flesh was so sensitive, she didn’t know if she could handle another. She’d adjusted to the two cocks pumping in and out of her, and they felt so good. The fullness, the completion was sending her higher and higher on a rising tide of erotic tension, her body coiling around the explosion that was readying in her core. Gritting her teeth, she tried to think of anything non-sexual, but it was hard with two men filling her holes. The very air smelled of sex.

When Todd massaged her breasts, she felt herself give way. Moving with them, between them, there was an even greater difference in the pleasure all three of them were experiencing. She rocked with them, rhythmically seeking her culmination. Clenching her muscles, her pussy and ass massaged their dicks, and both men moaned as she tightened around them. They picked up their speed, and Allison became caught in their rhythm, all three of them racing for the pinnacle, which was rapidly approaching.

She sobbed, screaming Todd’s name as the orgasm slammed into her, rocking her body as they lost control of their own pleasures, forcing their cocks into her simultaneously. A wordless wail of extreme ecstasy filled the air as they throbbed inside of her, filling her with hot liquid. Her nails dug into Todd’s shoulders as she convulsed, the overstimulation of her nerves and exhaustion, rising and taking her down into a floating sea of darkness.

* * *

Allison woke up in the dark and realized Todd had kept his word. The clock on his bedside stand said it was three a.m. She had been unconscious, and he hadn’t woken her, and her smaller body was trapped against his. She had been sleeping on her side with her back against his stomach, and he had her cuddled close to him with one arm and one leg spread possessively over her body. Wriggling a little, she realized he had a nighttime hard-on. She froze, then considered…

---