Page 16 of Calling Her Bluff

“I know he’s your step-cousin, Princess,” Todd said, wrapping his arm around her securely, so she had to stand at his side. He had to control himself not to laugh at the confused and desperate look that sentence produced. “It’s not like you two are related by blood, something he tells me you’ve emphasized to him as long as you’ve known him. From everything else he’d said, you’ve definitely enjoyed teasing him with your luscious body. Didn’t think he’d ever get the chance to touch what you were showing off, did you?”

Allison shook her head, and he started to move, trying to pull her forward. His eyes snapped with anger at her continued resistance, but she didn’t care. This was too much, too humiliating to be faced withChadof all people—the guy she’d tormented growing up, always safe in the knowledge he could never touch what she’d flaunted. Embarrassment reddened her cheeks as she realized how much he must already know about her and Todd.

“Todd, you can’t expect me to—” Her words were lost as he grabbed her by her hair and pushed her roughly against the wall.

SLAP! SLAP! CRACK!

There was no holding back as he drew his hand back high in the air and spanked her hard, without mercy, making her scream and dance as the pain reverberated through her butt cheeks. She cried out, begging him to stop, knowing he would ignore her ‘please’ and wishing it didn’t make her pussy spasm in excitement.

SLAP! SMACK! CRACK! THWACK!

Her ass was bright red when he finally stopped, pushing his body behind hers and trapping her between himself and the wall. She whimpered at the throbbing heat in her butt cheeks, humiliated Chad had just seen her spanked, in pain from the brutal spanking, and mortified to know if Todd tested her pussy right now, his fingers would come away soaked.

The words he spoke in her ear were low enough, only she could hear them. “I can’t believe I have to say this again. You are mine on these dates, and you will do what I say. You said you wanted to do everything. You were excited when you thought about being with two men, and I have decided to share what’s mine.” Reaching around to her front, he slid his hand between her body and the wall to cover one breast, pinching her nipple harshly and making her whimper.

“If you think that was an easy decision for me, you’re wrong, but you’re getting what you wanted, sweetheart, if not in quite the manner you thought. Although, as much as you’ve teased Chad through the years, it wouldn’t surprise me if you secretly fantasized about him. I know you now, and you wouldn’t have flashed him if you hadn’t enjoyed it. Now, if you don’t shape up and behave, I’m going to tie you over the couch and let him fuck your pussy until you cum, then I’ll throw you out of here for tonight without your coat,andyou’ll still owe me three more dates.”

As he spoke, he emphasized his words by pinching her nipple, making her writhe against him, the sensitive skin of her bottom scraping against the front of his pants. She could feel the bulge of his erection pressing between her ass cheeks, and her pussy ached for attention. She moaned. How could his threats get her so hot? Deep down, she felt sure he didn’t mean any of it, yet she found herself almost wanting him to. The bit of niggling doubt made her even hotter. Maybe being blackmailed into doing perverted things wasn’t just a way to get out of the guilt, maybe some part of her got off on being blackmailed… period.

Or maybe it was just Todd.

“Do you understand me?”

Allison nodded frantically, her hands against the wall as she pushed back against him, trapped by the muscular heat of his body. He wouldn’t need to do any of that to harm her—all he’d need to do is let one hint of her activities get back to her parents. Just yesterday at dinner, her father had been railing about the immorality of the world, especially the internet, and verbally abusing those girls who sold their bodies to make money. The worst part had been when he’d gone on to talk about her perfection, her upstanding morals, and how he was so proud of his daughter for her high standard of living.

The weight behind her eased, his fingers giving one last pinch of her hard nipple before he moved away. When she turned, face scarlet with mortification, Chad was watching them with a huge smile. Just seeing the snobby bitch get her ass slapped was almost enough to make up for everything she’d put him through as a teenager. He was thrilled Todd had offered to share her for the night. There were definitely advantages to being a frat brother. He had no idea how Todd had such a hold over the bitch-tease, but he didn’t really care. Todd had assured him Allison wasn’t going to be made to do anything she truly didn’t want, and that was good enough for him.

Allison, her mother, and her father had treated him and his Dad like second-class members of the family since his Dad had married Linda. He didn’t truly dislike Allison, despite her snobbery, because he could tell she was just a miniature version of her parents, taking their lead rather than thinking for herself. At least, he didn’t dislike her now. As a teenager, he’d hated her for all the hard-ons he’d had to hide, the blue balls she’d frequently left him with, and the upturned tilt of her nose every time she’d looked at him. By the time he got to college, he’d grown up enough to realize the flashes of her body had come from a rebellious exhibitionist streak, and underneath her social exterior, she seemed desperately unhappy.

Seeing her like this, despite her embarrassment, was a pleasure. She was more vibrantly alive than he’d ever seen her. He didn’t miss that both nipples were hard, not just the one Todd had been playing with, and the slight scent of her pussy that announced her arousal at the rough treatment. He was planning on enjoying tonight.

Gingerly, Allison sat at the table. Dinner was a strain for her, sitting butt-naked in front of two fully clothed men, wondering what they were going to do following the meal. Todd and Chad seemed comfortable, chatting about classes and frat activities. The fundraiser Todd was promoting had already raised more money than expected, and he’d raised their goals. She was interested to hear Chad’s compliments on Todd’s business acumen and good instincts. Throughout the conversation, she found her mind drifting, wondering what it was going to be like to be between them.

Had she had a crush on Chad in high school? He was good-looking. Even when he’d been a scrawny teenager, he’d been cute. There had been a lot of resentment between them, but she was honest enough at this point to realize she’d enjoyed his lustful looks he’d and had taken delight in teasing him. She still thought he was a slacker, but that didn’t stop the heat between her legs as she looked him over with the eyes of a woman, rather than the judgmental eyes of a girl.

Perhaps she should have been worried Chad would tell her father, but she doubted it. Her dad would throw a shit fit, and Aunt Linda would blow a gasket. Her secret should be more than safe. If Aunt Linda ever got mad enough, she’d cut off his access to money—the same hold her father had over her. Not that he’d ever had to threaten her with that. His emotional hold had always been strong enough to keep her from rebelling.

Finally, dinner was over. Todd got up from the table and snapped his fingers. Her pulse fluttered with anticipation as she got up, her cheeks pink from the witnessed humiliation, and followed him into the bedroom. Chad followed, watching her swaying ass above the lacy tops of her thigh-highs—her butt as pink as her other cheeks from the spanking Todd had given it earlier.

Both men shed their clothes, and Todd yanked back the covers on his bed to reveal the white sheets under the red comforter. Sitting on the bed, back against the headboard, with his legs spread, he motioned for Allison to join him. Crawling onto the bed, she immediately got into position to give him a blowjob, but to her surprise, he turned her around, so her back was leaning against his body.

Flushing, she realized why as Chad crawled on the foot of the bed, heading toward her, naked, his eyes riveted to her body. He really was a bit of a hunk with his short blonde hair, blue eyes, perfect white smile, and the tanned, lean muscular build of a year-round swimmer. She could also see he had a rather decent-sized cock, bobbing low in front of him.

She was trapped between them, unable to move away as he planted his hands on either side of her and lowered his mouth to hers. Although she was conflicted, she kissed him back. It was incredibly perverse, kissing someone who was technically family. Todd was right, she had never actually considered Chad to be her cousin, but it added a sense of the forbidden to their kissing, especially when his tongue pressed into her mouth, coaxing a response. She was very aware she was sandwiched between two men, kissing one while the other’s erection dug into her back.

Chad was thrilled at finally getting to touch Allison’s soft body, finally getting his hands on the luscious tits she’d teased him with. He squeezed them hard. Todd had told him she liked it a little rough. Allison groaned as the fondling of her sensitive breasts had its usual effect. Relinquishing the kiss, Chad lowered his mouth to her perfect pink nipple, and Allison closed her eyes and nestled her head back against Todd’s chest, tucking it under his chin, so she didn’t have to look. It was too embarrassing, having someone she’d always taunted, touching her so intimately.

“Watch him, Princess,” he ordered with a slight warning bite on her ear. “I want you to watch Chad while he touches you.”

Allison turned reluctant eyes to her chest, watching Chad suck her nipple like a starving baby. Without warning, he abandoned her breasts and slid down her body as Todd hooked his legs under hers, his feet pressing against the insides of her ankles, making her spread. She could see how sexy her body looked, the thigh-highs emphasizing the creamy ivory of her thighs and the pale, smooth mound at their apex. Chad dove mouth first into her open pussy, lapping hungrily at the juices pooling there as his frat brother spread her open.

Todd was manhandling her breasts as Chad’s eager tongue lashed her pussy. Todd’s nimble fingers stroked and pinched her nipples. Allison moaned as she realized, having two guys work over her body meant many parts of her would be attended to at the same time—an overwhelming cacophony of sensations for her to drown in. Chad slipped a finger into her sopping pussy as he tongued her clit, then slid another one in quickly, glorying in the wet tightness.

Todd’s hands were mauling her boobs, smashing them flat against her chest and squeezing them hard. Grasping them in his palms, he pulled them away, and her body tingled and throbbed at the rough treatment, her nipples aching for more direct attention. Allison’s hands were entangled in Chad’s blonde locks, pushing him against her pussy as the men manipulated her body. She felt as if her entire being had been taken over by pure pleasure.

With her hands in his hair, Chad realized she was swept up in the moment, urging him on to greater efforts. Slipping his two wet fingers out of her pussy, he roughly jammed them into her anus, shoving three fingers from his other hand into her pussy, and sucking her clit into his mouth.

Allison wailed, high-pitched, as her orgasm crashed into her. The pain his fingers had caused in her pussy and ass, stretching and burning as he thrust, had shoved her over the brink. Realizing she was cumming, Todd gripped her nipples tightly between his fingers, crushing the tender buds, and pulled them as far away from her body as he could, moving his hands quickly up and down. Her breasts bounced painfully, sharp jabs biting into her nipple as Chad rolled her clit between his teeth. Allison writhed, sobbed, and vaulted into another wave of pleasure, a few tears leaking from her eyes at the intensity of the orgasm.

---