Page 109 of Once Upon a Fake Date

“You don’t have to go slow,” she panted, looking at me over her shoulder. “Fuck me hard. Please,” she begged. Audrey wiggled her hips, trying to force me deeper inside, and I responded by slamming into her, feeding her my entire cock in one hard thrust.

“Is this what you wanted?” I asked, pressing against her wet body as she let out a moan.

She arched her back as I pounded into her deeper, thrusting over and over again as I experimentally swiveled my hips, testing her reaction. I might have been a virgin up until the last hour, but I was finding that learning Audrey’s body—the spots that made her cry out and how to make her feel good—was better than anything else I could have imagined.

Her cunt spasmed around me, gripping me tighter, and oh, fuck, it felt good. If I hadn’t already come once tonight, I would have lost it right then and there. Clenching my teeth, I focused on making her come again before I did. Reaching around us, I rubbed my thumb against her clit.

“Come for me, sunshine,” I rasped against her ear, feeling her shiver in response.

She let go, her pussy giving me a vice grip, milking me for my own release as her folds pulsed around me.So good.I groaned, feeling the telltale signs of my release coming on from the base of my cock, my balls tightening with need.

Pulling out, I let out a deep grunt as I spilled my cum over her back and the supple swell of her ass, painting her with my seed.

“Damn.” I swiped a finger through it, running my fingers through it to spell out my name before pulling her into my arms so I could wash it off of her. As much as I wanted to be a caveman and let her sleep with my scent all over her body, I also wanted her to be comfortable.

Audrey collapsed against me, letting out a little yawn.

I chuckled, picking her up as soon as we were both clean and setting her down on the bathmat so I could towel her dry before carrying her back to the bed.

Neither one of us bothered putting our clothes back on. I just slid in beside her, enjoying the feeling of her warm, naked body next to mine.

And we both promptly fell asleep in each other’s arms.

A few hours later,I had to sneak back into the room I was sharing before curfew checks. Coach might have cut me slack for starring in the musical and dating Audrey—both of which had been major distractions from his point of view—but I knew his policies when traveling with the team. Staying in my girlfriend’s room wouldn’t have gone over well. Besides, I’d need to get on the bus with everyone in the morning.

We all arrived together and left together, no exceptions.

So as much as I wanted to stay in Audrey’s arms, I’d left her a note on top of my red sweatshirt that she’d had stashed in her bag, pressed a kiss to her forehead, and headed up to the third floor.

My Rosie Girl,

I’ll see you back on campus. Last night was incredible, and I’m not sure I’ll ever forget it. Maybe you don’t realize how crazy I am about you, but it’s true. It was never fake to me. All this time, I was just waiting for you.

Drive safe. I have your location now, so I’ll track you in case anything happens. Still, call me when you’re back. Miss you already.

Your Dream Boy

The last fewweeks of the semester were always crazy, but this year, a certain amount of calm had descended over me. Like nothing could pop the bubble I was in with Audrey. She was my girl, and the sex was incredible. Though she hadn’t spent every night in my bed, I liked that this was real.

She was it for me. I was in this for the long haul. Even if that meant exposing the deepest truths of my heart to her.

We hadn’t said I love you yet, but I could feel it in every action. Every time we came together, making love in the quiet of my room. It was all around us, and yet… why were we holding back?

Practice was over for the day, and I’d already finished classes and hit the weight room, which meant I was free for the evening. Sure, I still had to study for finals that started in just a few days, but at least I had some free time.

I headed towards where my girl had told me she’d be, walking faster than normal because I missed her. God, I was a sap, missing her after only a few hours apart, but I couldn’t help it.

Entering the coffee shop, I saw her blonde hair and the cheery pink outfit she was wearing today. Audrey’s love for pink never failed to make my chest warm.

My face lit up as I headed towards her. She couldn’t see me from this angle, but as I approached, I saw she was sitting with Ella. I frowned as I realized I could hear their conversation.

“So, what’s going on between you?”

“I don’t know, Ells,” she sighed.

“But you said it was all fake, right?”

“Itwas,”she murmured, taking a sip of her iced coffee. “But I don’t know.”

---