Page 38 of The Puck Secret

I want her, but I can’t have her.

I want her, but she doesn’t want me.

That reminder is enough to have my own usual taunts sliding back out as I grin at her. “If I would have known your pussy was that good, I’d have snatched it up years ago, Princess.”

Her own eyes harden at my words, that familiar sparkle returning to them as she snaps, “Like I’d ever put myself through that misery again.” She pushes past me before the lie has barely fallen from her tongue, and rips open the door as I follow, but then falters as she sees that only Reign remains.

“You two sounded like you were having fun in there,” he purrs, wiggling his eyebrows, as he brings a joint up to his mouth and inhales deeply, before blowing the smoke back out. “I’m hard as fuck listening to you both.”

I feel Maddie’s spine straighten at his brazen comments, and jealousy curls inside my gut, but I have to remind myself she isn’t mine, she doesn’t want to be. Yet before I can cut in and defuse the tension, Maddie storms towards him and steals the joint right from his hand, taking a seat on the sofa across from him. As I walk towards her, my eyes tracking her every move, she inhales the joint in and out, before cocking her head at Reign.

“I know you aren’t familiar with making a girl come, Alexander, but I’m sure you know what it sounds like.” His name on her lips slices through me, as I slide into the spot beside her, snatching the joint from her just to stop myself from touching her.

Reign laughs, shaking his head as I pass the joint back to him, and he takes a drag before saying, “I like this one, she’s smart, you should keep her.”

Again I feel her tense beside me, but all I do is grab the bottle of whiskey from the table and smile. “I would try, but like you said, she’s smart.”

Ignoring our conversation completely, Maddie cuts in and asks again, “Where did everyone go?”

We can all still hear the party raging upstairs, but our little downstairs hang has dissipated quickly. Reign sighs, “I dared Hallie to kiss Archer, which she did, but then it got awkward so she left, but she told me to tell you she’s fine. Archer left with Jake and his girlfriend to take her home. And Daemon…” he starts, clearly not sure what to say. “Daemon got annoyed and left, I’m not really sure why.” He takes another drag of the joint in his hand, before he stubs it out on the table and leans back to watch us. “Clearly we didn’t have as much fun as the two of you,” he smirks, taking a sip of his drink, his drunken eyes flicking between the both of us.

I can hear the teasing tone in his voice, the flirty under edge to it. It’s typical Reign, but where I expect Maddie to back down and blush again, instead she spurs him on. “Then maybe I’ll invite you next time instead,” Maddie purrs, and my knuckles turn white from how tight I grip the bottle in my hand.

“Careful,” I warn quietly. This isn’t a game she wants to play with me, but instead of ignoring my warning, she turns to me and smiles. Suddenly all I can think about is the fact that the night she came to my room and sucked me off, she was looking for him, not me.

I keep my eyes locked on hers in silent caution, but when the smirk stays on her lips, I decide it’s time to play another game. I take another sip of whiskey and then I reach down and grab Maddie by the waist and drag her into my lap. She yelps a little as I do it, but when she tries to wiggle away, I lean up and whisper in her ear. “Are you trying to escape or turn me on again?”

My question has her freezing where she is, her resistance failing her as she tries to decide her next move, but I move my focus back to Reign, who is now staring at the point where Maddie and I are joined. I bring the bottle up to her mouth and when she turns to look down at me, I communicate with my eyes for her to take a drink. She is going to need it.

“Truth or dare, Princess?” I ask smiling, knowing she won’t back down, not when she missed her turn earlier.

“Truth,” she answers instantly, just like I knew she would. My predictable little princess, but little does she know this is a game I am desperate to win, especially when the prize is her.

“Why don’t you tellAlexanderhere about our first sexual encounter?” Her cheeks heat as she realizes what I am referring to, but then I see the determination in her eyes as she keeps her stare on mine.

“I asked him politely if I could suck his dick,” she says, not dropping my gaze, and I hear Reign chuckle as he watches us.

Nodding my head while taking another drink, I can’t help but tease her. “Cute recollection of events, Princess, now tell him who you were really looking for that night.”

I see a flicker of uncertainty flash across her stare, and when I just keep my smirk in place she huffs and flicks her head back to Reign. “I was originally looking for you because given your reputation, I thought you’d be an easy target.”

I smirk, seeing the flush of red now starting to burn up her chest as I take one final drink. “Did you hear that Reign?” I ask, tossing the now empty bottle of whiskey to the floor, and bringing my palms to slide up Maddie’s thighs. “The first night my girl put her mouth on me, she was actually looking for you.”

Turning my head towards him I can see he looks intrigued, clearly unsure of what game I am trying to play as he responds, “Well she looks pretty happy with where she ended up, Nineteen.”

“Mmm, she does, doesn’t she?” I bring my gaze back to hers, and almost drown in the look of restrained lust now burning in her stare. She doesn’t know what the game is, but she is desperate to play. Just like on the dance floor upstairs, I see her, I know her limits, and how she wants them to be pushed. I slide the hands on her thighs higher until one of them can completely cover her pussy as I whisper, “Why don’t you show him what I do to you?”

I feel her hesitation, she doesn’t want to give me this, she doesn’t want to need this, but I am quickly learning everything there is to know about the Mayor’s daughter. Only a few seconds tick by before she is spreading her thighs over mine, and if it wasn’t for my hand, Reign would be able to see her cunt completely. A cunt that now belongs to me, whether she wants to admit that or not.

Madeline Peters might be in denial, but I’m not, and it’s time to push her to the point of no return.

Heat floods my body as my swollen pussy pulses against Nova’s hand. I know he can feel it, I mean fuck, I can smell my arousal from here. Mix that with the touch of his fingers, and Alexander’s eyes focused solely on what his hand covers, I feel like I am about to combust. I have never done anything like this in my life. Hell, until an hour ago, I had never even had casual sex before. It had always been with a guy I was dating, or someone I pretended to like to appease my parents, but Nova pushes every boundary I have, yet I can’t help but think with this new game he is pushing his own even more.

I felt the possessive press of his hands against my skin, saw the look of desperation in his eyes as he fucked me. I felt it in the bathroom, that spark between us, it’s like we both took that hatred we had for one another and turned it into something completely different. Loathing him turned to lusting for him, especially as every inch of his cock sunk inside of me. With him, I’m not the Mayor’s daughter, or Thorne’s future fiancée, I’m not even Josh’s little sister, I am just me, and right now I am his.

His fingers flex against my pussy as he brings his mouth up to my ear. “Truth or dare, Princess?” Nova asks again, and I squirm against his hand as wetness begins to pool between my thighs.

Alexander’s eyes are burning into my flesh, noting every hitch in my breath, and every tremble in my body. I know he’s enjoying this, the same way I am, but how far is this really going to go? I press down into Nova’s body and feel the steel of his cock once again, hard against my ass as I bite back a moan. I know what he wants, what he needs, more than I should, and I don’t feel any regret as I whisper the word, “Dare.”

---