Page 67 of Beneath the Surface

I pulled down his pants along with his boxers and his dick sprang free. He was long and hard, the tip of his dick leaking with precum. His head hit the wall as I took him deep into my mouth.

“Shit,” he hissed as I began to suck him.

I took him as deep as I could go, gagging around his dick as he hit the back of my throat. I could tell Micah liked this because as soon as I did it his dick twitched in my mouth.

When I pulled back, you could hear the pop his dick made as he left my mouth.

He let out a ragged breath, then finally made eye contact with me again.

“You can fuck my mouth if you want to,” I whispered, and watched as his nostrils flared.

His hand came down and his thumb played with my lower lip.

“You’re so fucking pretty,” he told me as he pushed his thumb inside of my mouth. His pupils dilated even more when I sucked it. He pulled it out and then guided his dick into my mouth. “But the way you look sucking me off…fuck.”

This time he grabbed the back of my head, gripping onto my hair as he began to fuck my mouth. My eyes watered, and my pussy got wetter. I needed him, but I also wanted to give him this.

I began to move my hands in tandem with my mouth. Micah’s breath got uneven, his thrusting faster.

“Shit…baby,” he groaned, and I felt desire spread all over me. “I’m going to…pull…if…”

Ignoring him, I took him in deeper and let him finish inside of my mouth.

I had barely pulled back when we both jumped at the sound of Grayson calling our names. Micah fixed his pants as I got up. Grayson’s and Cruz’s voices sounded a bit erratic, and Micah immediately opened the door.

The four of us looked at one another. Grayson’s mask was pulled up on top of his head. His eyes were wild, and I bet it was due to the fact that he hadn’t been able to find us.I was glad that Grayson and Cruz were close enough and broad enough that they blocked the rest of the partygoers from seeing me. I was sure I was a hot mess.

Grayson looked at Micah, and then at me. Something about my face made his eyes flash with hurt, but I couldn’t pinpoint what.

“What happened?” Micah asked, his eyes on Gray.

When I turned to look at Micah, I noticed he was looking at him the same way he used to look at me when he thought he couldn’t have me.

Grayson’s throat bobbed before he spoke.

“We got worried when we couldn’t find you two anywhere.”

My cheeks flamed, but all I could do was look apologetic. Cruz, who had been right behind Grayson, took a step forward with a mischievous smile. His eyes were on Micah as he leaned down toward me. I could feel his lips on my ear as he spoke.

“You missed some, princess.”

I held my breath at his words. But then he moved his face a few centimeters and as his tongue peeked out to lick the corner of my lip, my gaze got caught on Grayson’s.

38

GRAYSON

Ava’s eyes burned into mine as Cruz slowly and deliberately licked the remains of Micah’s cum from the corner of her mouth. Micah was staring at Cruz, his cheeks flushed, and I had that same feeling that had hit me back at the lake, like it was the three of them on one side and I was on the other.

Except…Ava’s expression seemed almost inviting. I couldn’t be reading that properly, could I?

I swallowed, pulling my mask down over my face. From behind it, maybe I could gather myself and act like the fucking leader I was supposed to be, before shit started falling apart around us. It felt like there was quicksand all around me, and I was trying to grip onto something, but the grains were running through my fingers and sucking me down at the same time?—

“Gray.Gray.”

I blinked, realizing that Ava was now right in front of me, her heated gaze gone, replaced with concern. And that was a fucked-up situation. I was, in theory, the most desirable guy here tonight—and no, I wasn’t that arrogant, but hockey captain equaled opportunities not afforded to others. But instead of thegirl I wanted flirting with me and pressing her hot body up against mine, she was clasping my arm and trying to peer into my eyes behind my mask.

“I’m fine,” I bit out, stepping backward. She exchanged glances with Micah, something unspoken passing between them, and then she was gently lifting my mask.

---