Page 144 of Muted

Sliding my free hand under her thigh to open her further for me, I plant my knee on the keys to get higher, bringing myself right back to the edge. “Fuck, I’m going to come inside you, Susu,” I groan out.

“You want him to finish you off right now, baby? Or do you want both of us to fuck you?” My hips stutter in surprise at Theo’s suggestion, pulling me back as I jerk my head up to him. He’s eyeing me with a challenge and seriously, fuck him if I’m not going to meet it.

Nodding in her direction, I say to him, “Only if it’s what she wants.”

Chester chuckles from the couch. “She wants it. Just look at her.”

I’m not shocked that he’s got his cock in his hand, but maybe surprised by his comfortability with all of us like this. If we’re going to do this thing, all be with her at the same time, I think that’s what I’d want for her. No walls, no shyness. I need to resolve myself to get to know them as well because I’m positive we’re all in this for the long haul with her.

Dropping my gaze to my girl, I study her face with blown pupils and a flush of excitement spreading across her gorgeous chest and cheeks covered with a sheen of sweat. She nods her head quickly, giving us permission to change the game up.

I flash my teeth with a quick smile. “Wrap your legs around me again,” I order, keeping myself planted inside of her. Lifting her from the piano, I see Chester and Theo quickly shoving the coffee table over to the side to open up space in the middle of my living room. There’s a plush area rug in the center and that’s where I take her.

Carefully lowering us to the ground, she clings to me, circling her hips gently to keep herself on the cusp. As soon as I lay my body over hers, I thrust once, forcing her to grunt with how hard it is, then flip us over so she’s sprawled on top of me.

“Babygirl, have you done anal before?” Chester asks her, finding his seat once more on the couch. I didn’t see him do it, but he’s also stripped himself free of his clothes and now he’s stroking his cock with long, slow tugs.

“I tried it once a long time ago,” she answers breathlessly, turning her head with her cheek resting on my chest to answer him.

I feel Theo settling on his knees behind her, so I widen my legs to give him space, shallowly fucking her pussy as her juices drip down my shaft. Running my hand up her side, I can’t stop myself from saying, “Jesus, you’re wet, songbird. You like putting on a show for us, don’t you?”

Shoving her body up, using my chest as leverage, she sits down to take me all the way in. Hanging her head back, Theo groans as he gathers her hair in a fist, tugging hard to arch her further.

“I do,” she pants out, picking up her pace as she circles her hips over me, grinding her clit against me.

Sitting up to join her, I wrap my hand around her neck and yank her mouth to mine, whispering, “I do too.” Flicking my eyes to Chester for a split second, I smile just enough that she can feel it. “Let’s give him a show, hmm?”

Letting her mouth slide across mine, she turns her head again to look at him over her shoulder. Theo has been running his hand up and down her back this entire time, tugging at himself at the same time.

I lay back and almost immediately, Theo’s hand is pressing her to lie against me. I can feel his eyes where I’m joined with her. “Pull out for a minute, Vance. Let me get myself wet in her. Baby, we’re not going to fuck you here tonight,” he says, and the way she gasps lets me know he’s playing with her asshole. “But someday soon.”

Hissing in through my teeth, I lift her hips to slip myself free, my dick slapping wetly against my lower abdomen. Theo doesn’t hesitate to dig his fingers into her hip before lining himself up and working himself inside of her.

“Christ, baby, always so fucking tight,” he grits out before thrusting hard and burying himself.

With a loud cry, Susu’s tits graze my chest as her body slides up my body, and she slams her hand on the floor next to my head to brace herself.

Goddamn, he doesn’t hold back with her. Kicking his hips forward, there’s no build up as he drives into her faster and faster. Susu buries her face in my neck as she moans against each thrust, and I wrap my arms around her back and head to hold her steady as Theo takes her.

My cock is pulsing as her pussy grazes the underside of my shaft and head on every pass. Lifting my hips, I grind myself against her skin harder until I can’t take it anymore. “I need in,” I grunt out and with a loud growl, Theo pulls out only for me to replace him.

This time when I fuck into her, she’s screaming as I bounce her over me. Theo and I alternate like this for a few minutes, taking turns stretching her, readying her to take both of us. I hear Chester’s loud breaths as he watches, getting more and more turned on as he watches the three of us.

Theo is panting as he settles his hand on her lower back to slow us down. “Hold still. Baby, can I try to fuck you at the same time?”

She’s practically delirious with pleasure as she drags her lips across my chest to rest against me, staring at Chester once more. “Please,” she moans out, her voice scratchy from the way we had her crying out.

I don’t let myself stay buried inside of her all the way, keeping about half of my length inside of her. We all suck in a gasping breath as Theo notches the head of his cock against her opening and my shaft.

I’ve got a solid hold on her, pinning her chest to mine, so he releases his grip on her hips and grasps the fleshy globes of her ass to spread her wide. Leaning back, he watches as he slowly surges forward, then barks out with relief when his head pops inside. The moment he’s there, I can feel the heat of his cock sliding against mine.

We all groan at how unbelievably tight it is with both of us inside of her. Theo’s chest is heaving quickly, sweat dripping from his forehead as he hangs his head low, pulling back slightly before pushing in harder, gaining more ground.

“So… much…” Susu pants out brokenly. Brushing her hair from her brow, I peek down at her, only to find her eyes wide and watching Chester’s fist move up and down his length.

“I have to move, songbird,” I grit out. I’ve been trying to hold still while Theo got himself settled, but my blood is pounding in my ears, and I already feel close to bursting.

Her answer is to roll her hips over both of us, Theo dropping his head back to stare at the ceiling from the way she feels. “Fuck me,please,” she begs. Her voice is so soft, but filled with need and I know that we all heard her.

---