Page 109 of Muted

“Y-yes…” I stutter, my breathing turning ragged as I feel my pussy clench down on him just the way Theo said it would.

“There she goes,” Theo mutters, stepping closer and wrapping his hand around my throat. “Fuck her through it,” he demands, his words sending me over the edge.

I scream out my release as I fall forward against Theo, Vance’s hands dropping to my hips and gripping them to keep me in place. Digging his fingers in, he holds me on him as he drives his cock into me at a rapid pace as I fall apart, my hands flying out to grab onto Theo as I convulse through my release.

“Goddamnit!” Vance curses, roaring as he drives himself into me hard, fighting through my pussy that’s doing everything it can to suffocate him. I have no control as I sob through the intense pleasure, his cock swelling where I fear he’ll tear me in two.

Theo’s free hand grasps my hair and yanks back so I’m looking up at him, my mouth open as I moan again, another tremor racing through my body. He slams his lips across mine, drinking down my sounds. Another body shaking orgasm shoots through me, and I clamp my teeth on his lower lip, forcing him to growl at the pain before he wrenches his head away.

I notice a hint of red on his lip before he licks it away, and a feral grin stretches across his face. “Biting will get your beautiful ass bent over my knee, carebear.” He finishes his threat with another hard kiss, his fingers tightening around the front of my throat slightly to keep me still.

Vance releases the grip he has on one side of my hips, grabbing my chin to yank my mouth from Theo’s. With his hand on my chin, he turns my face to him and drives his tongue into my mouth, groaning again when I tilt my hips against him hard.

“I want to come inside of you,” he begs, and I nod my head, wanting it more than I want air to breathe. When I give him my permission, he grabs my waist and throws me onto the bed, letting his cock slip from my body.

Scrambling to my hands and knees, I feel him yank my lower body back just before he slams back inside, fucking hard and fast. The sound of our skin slapping together is obscene, but all I can do is bury my face into my blanket and scream as he yells out his release.

Three, four, five more hard thrusts and he holds his body against mine and I feel him pulse with every surge of cum that he empties inside of me. Another smaller orgasm races through me and I turn my head to cry as my body shakes under him.

Vance slides out a bit, then pushes in, another pulse of his orgasm empties into my abused body, and I’m so fucking here for it. We both stay frozen in the aftermath, bodies jolting with tremors before I’m able to crack an eye open.

I immediately find Theo’s face only a foot from mine. He’s leaning over the bed, hands pressed into the mattress as he hovers over me. His eyes are running over my face, presumably to check on how I’m doing.

Whatever he finds written there has him quirking his lip up in a half smile. “You come beautifully, you know that?” he asks, his tone low, then leans down and kisses the side of my neck softly.

Vance chuckles just before he slowly pulls himself free from my body with a disappointed sigh. “I would have to agree. Fucking gorgeous.”

I twist my head around to peer up at him and a surge of appreciation for the both of them fills me from head to toe. This couldn’t have been easy for them, both being here during a moment like this. I know I have to eventually decide who I’d like to be with, but right now I don’t want to.

They both mean so fucking much to me and my heart hurts knowing they want a choice to be made. Then there’s Chester. What about him? He’s not here right now, but he makes me feel alive and protected andimportant. Theyalldo.

I’m jerked from my thoughts when Theo’s heavy hand smacks my ass with a laugh. “You need to take a shower and get to work. Isn’t Chaz picking you up soon?”

Fuck!

Jerking up to a sitting position, I search for my phone. When I see it on my side table, I scramble across the bed, ignoring the fact that they both have a perfect view of my naked ass. Turning it on, I see that I’ve only got about twenty minutes before Chester is supposed to arrive and I begin to panic.

“I have to shower!” I cry out, tossing my phone to my bed.

The two of them chuckle as I hurl myself from my bed, then laugh in earnest when I glare at both of them. Standing up to my full, pathetically short height, I plant my hands on my hips.

“I’m not sure what you find so hilarious, but you’ve both uninvited yourself to join me in the shower.” I smirk at the way their smiles immediately disappear, frowning at me like I’ve taken away their favorite toy. “Vance?” I ask, turning to him.

He steps closer, still completely naked. I move into his body and drop my head back to look up at him. “That was…” I trail off, not knowing what to say.

Not leaving me to fumble for words, he wraps his hands around the sides of my neck and kisses me softly. Then breathes out, “It was everything,” against my lips. Nodding briefly, I let my mouth slide against his with the motion.

“It was. I’ll see you in a bit at the bar,” I whisper.

Another quick kiss, and he smiles. “Soon.” Then he gathers his clothes to get dressed as I move over to Theo.

He doesn’t wait for me, instead choosing to hook a thick arm around my waist to lift me into his arms. When we’re at eye level, I cup his face and look into his eyes. Leaning forward, I press our foreheads together and close my eyes, breathing deeply.

“Thank you for being here,” I murmur, then press a kiss to the bridge of his nose. His soft laugh warms me, and he hugs me closer to his chest.

“I’m glad I was here. That was… hard to watch, but also fucking sexy. You’re really beautiful when you’re like that.” He pauses, fighting with something, then adds, “I want to be here for all of it. I don’t want you to decide just yet.”

His confession rocks me, and I stare at him for a moment. Then decide to give him my own. “I can’t decide, Theo. I justcan’t.” It’s hard to admit, and I can tell that he understands when he gives me a forced smile filled with understanding.

---