Page 90 of Gratification in Gluttony

The bottle of lube clicked, then chilly, slick fingers slipped between Toni’s asscheeks to circle his hole. It had been a while since anyone had fucked Toni like this, so he closed his eyes and fought to stay relaxed as Jude gently, patiently opened him up.

His fingers fisted in the sheets when Jude added a third finger, a coarse sound escaping him as he bared down. Jude’s fingers were relatively small, but he still worked them deep, like he was searching for something.

“What feels good, Toni?” Jude asked, breathing hard like he was the one about to get fucked instead of Toni.

“Everything you’re doing feels good,” Toni managed to say. “But I’m most sensitive around my rim, if that’s what you mean.”

“Oh,” Jude said in surprise, pulling his fingers out to play more shallowly. “Like this?”

Toni could only moan in response as his nerve-endings started firing with pleasure. Some species needed deep penetration, but Toni’s pleasure spots were centered much closer to his rim. It was why he loved getting fucked by Lupyns or Incubi. Their knots felt like they were specifically designed to have him flying.

It was also why he’d chosen the dick for Jude to use like he had. It had been textured around the base, not a knot but bumpy, almost like the dull spines of a Nyko dick. It was going to feel great, Toni just knew it.

“You need to fuck me,” Toni said, pushing back on Jude’s fingers. “Please, just fuck me.”

“You still wanna ride me, baby?” Jude asked as he withdrew his fingers. “Or do you want me to fuck you like this?”

Both were perfectly acceptable, but Toni wanted to see Jude’s face as he impaled himself on his cock for the first time. So he lifted himself off the mattress with trembling arms. “I’m gonna ride you.”

“Good.” Jude settled himself against his headboard and slid the condom down his cock.

Toni sat back on his heels as he watched. “Can you come like this too?”

See-sawing one hand, Jude lubed up the dildo with the other. “Sometimes, if the pressure’s right. But not always, and that’s okay. I mean, you made me come twice already.”

“Still,” Toni said, leaning in to kiss Jude messily, all tongues and teeth. “Want you to come with your dick up my ass.”

“I’ll do my best,” Jude teased.

Grinning sharply, Toni licked across Jude’s mouth. “Get ready for the ride of your fucking life.”

“You talk a big game, pretty boy,” Jude said as Toni grabbed the headboard with one hand as the other threaded through Jude’s hair.

“And Toni’s gonna deliver, baby,” he promised as he found his balance, feet on either side of Jude’s hips. “Hold it steady for me.”

Jude rubbed Toni’s side with one hand as the other reached between them to angle his dick where Toni needed. A growl erupted from his chest as the tip of Jude’s dick pressed to his asshole. He slowly sat back on it, feeling it stretch his rim in a way that had his thighs shaking already.

“Easy,” Jude said, fingers tracing the place where Toni was impaling himself on his dick. “Fuck, Toni, you’re so beautiful like this. Look at you, taking my dick so good.”

“I’ll take it so good,” Toni grunted out as he rolled his hips to take it deeper. “Shit, I need more lube.”

“Okay.”

As Toni lifted off, Jude applied more lube to the dildo, then pushed two fingers into Toni’s ass, getting everything wet and messy. Then they went again, the glide easier now.

“You okay?” Jude asked, breath hot and heavy against Toni’s cheek.

Toni nodded. “Yeah, it’s just been a while. Fuck, you feel good.”

It took a minute or two for Toni to take the whole length, but when the textured base rubbed against his rim, his head dropped back with a pathetic whine. He ground down on it, making Jude grunt.

“There you go. Make yourself feel good.” Jude dug his fingers into Toni’s waist, and Toni nodded. He was already feeling good as he dug in his heels and started to bounce on Jude’s cock.

Now, Toni liked going to the gym, and he thought he was in pretty good shape, muscles lean but tight. But he’d been slacking on leg day or something because his thighs were screaming already, and all four of his lungs were heaving, gills flaring uncomfortably as he forced them to breath dry oxygen.

“I need to do more cardio,” Toni said as he slowed his pace, and Jude laughed weakly.

“You’re doing just fine from my perspective.”

---