Page 197 of Tangled up in You

“Deal.” Finn is next.

“I’m the easy one. Call it a deal,” Koa responds, and I look at Cas.

“What do you say?” Wrapping my arms around his neck, I lick at his bottom lip, and his arms tighten around me.

Cas nods before he answers. “Yes. Deal.”

“So, no jealousy, fighting, or anything else.” He nods again.

“I’ll try not to be jealous, but I’m fucking you first. You’re mine, Ry. That means no more random guys, or I’ll end up in jail.”

Words I’ve longed to hear, and as an answer, I peel off my t-shirt and toss it aside. “Deal.” A squeal rips from my lips as he flips me over onto my back, and my shorts are yanked off my body.

“I’m not sure you understand what you’re signing up for,” Cas says, his voice rough with the edge of a growl. I wish I could see him better. I love the possessive look he gets in his eyes, and I can picture it now. My breath shudders out, and my stomach clenches as he crawls between my legs. He rubs the head of his cock against me, and my heart beats faster than it has since my first time. Is this actually happening? I half expect him to jump up and say he can’t go through with it.

A light flickers in the corner, and I realize that someone has lit a candle just as Cas pushes himself partway inside me and then stops. I arch my back and press up with my hips, wanting to feel all of him. I can just make out his eyes with the added light, and they are feral and full of lust. My pussy clenches, and he sucks in a deep breath but still doesn’t move.

“Fuck, you’re so tight. Please tell me you’re on something,” he says, his lips touching mine.

I nod. “I have an IUD.”

He groans. I scream as he shoves the rest of his cock into me. He is not quite as thick as Quinn, but he’s longer and stops right on the point of pleasure and pain.

“Fuck, fuck, fuck.” Capturing his mouth, I swallow down every swear word and groan, my heart filling with happiness like he’s my fuel. “I’m not going to last. I’ve wanted you for so long, Ry.”

I smile, loving the out-of-control feeling he is experiencing and that it’s because of me. “We have all night,” I whisper in his ear, and he shudders. Wrapping my legs around his waist and tracing my nails along his shoulders up into his hair, I pull him as close as I can. Cas buries his head into the side of my neck, and the moment he starts to give me a hickey, I know he is serious about this, about us. I remember one of his girlfriends begging him to give her a hickey so she could show it off. Listening to her beg after Cas’s flat-out refusal still makes me want to gag and claw her eyes out. His pace is blinding, the old bed bounces as he pounds into my pussy, and what I’m sure will be my first of many orgasms is rising quickly.

The other guys are standing close to the bed, their heated stares on us. It’s so erotic knowing they are watching. Cas slips his hands under my ass and lifts me higher off the bed, and the new angle has me yelling his name as the climax rushes to the peak and pushes over. Cas’s unrelenting thrusts force the pleasure to continue in waves, and I happily ride each one.

“Fuck yes, oh sweet fucking God, Ry.” Cas freezes, his muscles flexing hard under my touch as his cock unloads. He slumps on top of me and kisses me softly. “You’re incredible.” I smile, heat rushing to my face with the compliment.

“Cas, get out of the way. It’s our turn,” Quinn says from right beside me, his hand stroking his cock. From my very first orgasm, I’ve been addicted to the rush of sex and making myself come a dozen times a day. This…this is heaven.

Reaching out, I wrap my hand around his unbelievably hard cock. He groans as I grip him tighter and take over, jerking him off. I look up at Cas, and for a second, I think he’s going to argue, but instead, he kisses the tip of my nose before pushing himself up and out of the way.

Quinn pulls on my hand as he lays down, and I straddle him, lining him up with my quivering pussy. I toss my head back with a moan as his thick girth and swollen cock head pushes me open wider. Every inch I sit feels incredible as his fingers dig into my hips.

“Fuck me, you’re hot and so wet,” Quinn groans as I finally get all of him inside of me. I’ve never been with more than one guy in a night, and thinking of multiple guys coming in me more than once unlocks the deepest and darkest of my desires and sets them free.

“Finn, Koa, come here.” There is no hesitation as they get on the bed and seem to know what I want as they each take a side. I grip them and stroke the stiff shafts as I bounce on Quinn’s cock. His hands keep me steady as I lean toward Finn and suck him into my mouth.

“Oh fuck, that feels so good,” Finn says as I tease him with my tongue. Sucking him as deep into my mouth as I can, I bob my head and lose myself in the feel of the three of them. Switching to Koa before he gets too close to coming, I repeat the process and moan as Quinn pistons up into my pussy.

Koa rubs at my breast and rolls my nipple between his fingers as Finn reaches down and rubs my clit. The sound of skin slapping and heavy grunting is loud in the room, and I scream around Koa’s dick as my second climax rolls over me.

“Fuck, Ry, you have a tight little cunt. I want to pummel it.”

Pulling my mouth away from Koa, I look down at Quinn. “Do it, fuck me hard.”

The growl he gives me in response sends shivers racing down my spine. I’m a blubbering mess as he does just that, and it feels like he is going to split me in two. I’m near delirious as I turn to continue servicing Finn’s cock this time. He grips my head, and holds my face still as he begins fucking in time to his brother’s thrusts.

I know the moment Quinn is coming, his movements turn erratic, and then he pushes up so hard that it feels like he’s rubbing against my cervix, but there is this undeniable need in me that wants the bite of pain.

“Fuck me!” Quinn yells as he comes, and I can feel his cock kicking with every powerful release. We are both panting by the time he is done, but I don’t have time to take a break as Koa pulls me off Quinn and positions me on all fours.

He slams into me from behind as Finn moves in front of me and continues to fuck my face until drool is dripping from the corners of my mouth. My arms shake, but I’ve never been happier. I don’t notice Cas moving under me, but I know it’s him as soon as he sucks my nipple into his mouth. First one and then the other before burying his face between them and nipping at my sensitive skin.

“Ah! Fuck,” Koa yells as he comes and slowly pulls out. My well-used pussy is sensitive, but only excitement fills me as Finn moves around to take his turn. He pulls me up so that my back is against his chest and lies down.

---