“When you were all with that woman, I realized that everything I do has begun to revolve around you. I love my job,” she adds quickly. “But I need a life too. I don’t want to be alone forever, so I thought maybe I could find that at Club Sin.”

“You wanted to find a boyfriend at a sex club?” I ask dryly.

Selena glares at me, but it’s less harsh than before. “Yes. A man who might enjoy sex the way I do and isn’t so…vanilla.”

I’ll confess the thought of her with anyone other than us has my blood boiling in my veins. But my irritation is tempered at knowing our girl is kinky, just like we are.

“Glad to hear we might all be interested in some of the same things.” Brody smiles at her.

“I have another question,” she declares. “You said this would be exclusive, right?”

Chance responds right away. “Absolutely. There would be no one outside the four of us.”

“Okay. So what would that look like?” She subtly shakes her head, and I can only assume she’s trying to make sense of it all.

Brody grabs her hand and holds it between his palms. “If you agree to try this with us, then you would be completely ours. Ours to spoil, ours to fuck, ours to play with.”

“Play with?”

“Club Sin has numerous rooms where members can engage in all kinds of kink. And we’ll definitely be engaging with you,” I answer her question.

Selena swallows, then turns to face Brody. “What’s your kink?”

His mouth spreads into a wide grin. “Breath play. I like knowing that I decide how much you can handle. I control if you live or die. But it’s your trust in me that gets me off, knowing that I’ll never hurt you and only bring you pleasure.”

Her thighs clench together and she wets her lower lip. “O-okay.”

“Is that something you’ve explored before?” he asks.

“Yes. I… I like it.” She blushes a pretty shade of pink and my cock begins to stir. Then, she looks at me and Chance. “And you? What do you two like?”

Chance answers first. “Bondage is my favorite. I have various implements that I like to use. Rope, cuffs, spreader bars…”

She appears to smile at the thought.

“Fire. I like to play with fire,” I say. Selena’s gaze shoots to mine and her mouth drops open. “Are you into that?”

“Well, I… I’ve never tried.”

“Hmm, something new for you then.” I smirk, excited to see her delicate flesh set ablaze for the briefest of moments, completely under my control. “Anything else you want to ask?”

“Just to be clear… You all have been avoiding me and running away from me not because you don’t like me. But because you’re actually attracted to me?” There’s a hint of pain in her voice and I hate that we put it there.

Brody crouches down in front of her and takes her hands in his. He kisses each of her knuckles before looking into her eyes. “We never meant to upset you or make you feel that way. You’re the best at what you do and we didn’t want to fuck that up. Plus, we weren’t sure if you could handle us or that you’d even want to try. We’re sorry if we hurt you.”

She relaxes in her chair as he continues to hold her hands.

“We want to be with you, Selena, and we promise we’ll never make you feel that way again.”

Chance stands and moves to her side. “Beautiful, if you agree to be with us, I swear I’ll only ever spoil you from now on. You have my word.” He brushes her cheek with his thumb.

The three of them look in my direction, giving me the opportunity to respond. “I can’t take back what I did and I’m sorry. You’ve had me—had all of us—twisted up in knots for months. You drive me crazy and it’s made me do some stupid things.” I rise from my seat and walk over to them. “But I promise not to do that again. We want to try this with you. I don’t know if it’ll work out, but you’re the only woman we’ve ever wanted to do this with. That means something to me and I hope it does to you as well.”

She’s quiet for a while, staring at her lap, then each of our faces. “Does that mean I can call you my boyfriends now?” She smirks.

“I’m definitely not a boy,” Chance replies with a raised eyebrow.

“What am I supposed to call you then?”