Page 53 of The Very Naughty List

REID

My cock,already hard as hell, pulses as I listen to the filthy words pouring from Hailey’s lips. And when she tacks on that last sentence, her eyes flashing with a challenge, I nearly lose whatever threads of control I had left.

Fucking hell. I should’ve known this girl could ruin me.

She’s so fucking feisty, bratty and sassy in a way that drives me wild.

Naked and spread out on the bed like this, totally vulnerable and willing, she’s fucking gorgeous. It’s wrong to be thinking about my best friend’s sister like this, to be talking to and treating her the way I am. I’ll probably go to hell for this, but I don’t care.

I’ve wanted Hailey for years, but I could never act on it. I knew better. Lucas would kill me if he found out the thought had ever even crossed my mind, and I don’t blame him. If the roles were reversed and he was going after my sister, I’d beat his ass to a pulp too.

But judging from the way Sebastian and Nick are eating Hailey up like she’s the best thing they’ve ever tasted, I know I’m not the only one who’s been craving her. I sensed my brotherswere into her before now, even though we never talked about it, and this just confirms it.

And clearly, Hailey’s been hiding some feelings of her own. She’s always had a bit of an edge to her, despite her soft exterior, but I had no idea it ran this deep. I’m almost shocked at the demanding way she just ordered us to make her come.

And I’d be lying if I said it didn’t drive me crazy. So if that’s what this filthy little fiend wants, who am I to say no?

I slide my hand through her hair, palming the back of her head as I kiss her deeply, then pull back to stroke her cheek with my thumb. “Good girl. You did a very good job telling us what you want.”

“And yet here I lie, still waiting,” she sasses me, a smirk tugging at her lips even as her cheeks flush. I’d never tell her this, but I love the brattier side of her because it brings out my most dominant instincts. There’s nothing hotter than a sassy little vixen who’s just begging to be tamed.

“Then get on all fours,” I order, and her eyes flame.

“Oh, now you’re gonna make me do all the work?” she banters back, although she does what she’s told.

Sebastian and Nick lean back to give her room to maneuver, and as soon as she’s on her hands and knees with her beautiful, perky little ass pointing up in the air, I bring a hand back and clap it hard against one of her perfectly round cheeks. She yelps in surprise but moans as she glances over her shoulder at me with a glint in her wide, expressive green eyes.

“Do it again,” she breathes quietly, so I bring my hand down against the other cheek.

“I’m sorry, I couldn’t hear you,” I say over the cry that pours from her lips. My cock pulses at the sight of her wet, glistening pussy and the bright red handprints blooming on both of her ass cheeks.

“I said do it again,” she begs, her voice louder this time.

Fuck. She’s gonna kill me.

I share a look with my brothers, who are both clearly thinking something along the same lines. Then I lift my hand and spank her right ass cheek three times in quick succession. She cries out, her arms wobbling and giving way. Her upper body drops lower as she buries her face in the sheets, arching her back like she’s silently begging for more. She’s so wet now that it’s running down the inside of her leg.

Her ass is so red that it looks like a perfect, fresh strawberry, and I brush my fingertips across the marks I’ve left on her, imagining how good it would feel to sink my teeth into that plump flesh. Goosebumps spread across her skin as she shivers under my touch.

“Fuck,” she mewls into the sheets. “God,fuck, Reid.”

Hearing my name on her lips like that makes me feel almost primal, nearly out of control. All the desire for her that I’ve been holding back for years is rising like a tidal wave inside me, and I don’t think I can hold it back anymore. It’ll tear me apart if I try, and I can’t resist her. Not when she’s kneeling, soaked, and begging for my cock like this.

I can’t wait. I need to be inside her.

I’ve never shared a girl like this with my brothers before, but it feels right with Hailey. If ever there was the perfect woman for us to do it with, it’s her. We all know her better than almost anyone else, and that’s probably why we were all fighting so hard to win her over even though the whole thing was supposed to be fake.

None of us could ever just sit back and let the others have her. I can’t speak for Nick and Sebastian, but seeing her with either of them would’ve eaten me alive with jealousy. But working together to get her off? Shit, that’s easy.

“Quit torturing me and fuck me already,” Hailey mumbles into the sheets, rocking her hips back as if searching for a cock to fill her up.

I have to show her who’s really in charge here, so I thrust a finger all the way inside her, filling her up until she cries out, her head lifting off the mattress as her back arches.

Nick takes the opportunity to reach under her for her nipple, working it between two fingers while I roughly add a second finger and drive them both in and out of her. If she wants me to fuck her like a hungry little whore, then that’s exactly what I’ll do.

“Condoms?” I grunt, moving into place behind her as Sebastian tucks a lock of Hailey’s wavy honey blonde hair behind her ear.

“I’m on the pill.” Hailey shakes her head as she rocks forward and backward on my fingers, squeezing and pulling them deeper into her like she can’t get enough. “Are you all clean?”

---