Page 132 of The Very Naughty List

He leaves me hanging and disappears out of the room for a few seconds. I have no idea what’s about to happen until he returns with a blindfold dangling from one finger and a few feet of rope thrown over his shoulder.

“Where did you…?”

He shrugs. “After I read your bucket list, I had a feeling we might be needing some supplies, so I picked some up. I like to be prepared.”

My skin erupts in goosebumps as Nick and Sebastian kneel on either side of me, each man holding one of my arms in their hands. They position me just how they want me while Reid approaches and fits the blindfold over my eyes, then loops the rope around each of my wrists and ties them both to the bed posts.

“Is everything okay?” Sebastian asks, temporarily lifting the blindfold so I can see his face. “The ropes aren’t too tight?”

“No, they’re fine.”

“Good.” He drops the blindfold again and checks the tie in the back. “Can you see anything through this?”

I shake my head, and the bed creaks as someone climbs off the mattress. A second later, I jump when a hand meets my rib cage and fingers tickle down it like a set of piano keys.

“She’s telling the truth,” Sebastian informs Reid and Nick, so it must have been him testing me.

“Oh, this is gonna be fun,” Nick says, and I can hear the smile in his voice. It makes my nipples harden.

Tied up and blindfolded like this, I’m completely at their mercy. I won’t know what’s coming or from where, who’s touching or fucking me. They can do whatever they want, and all I can do is lie back and enjoy the ride.

God, this is even better than my fantasies. Because it’s with all of them.

The bed creaks as someone kneels on my right side, and I hold my breath in anticipation.

“If it’s ever too much, just say so, and we’ll stop, okay?” Reid asks. I nod quickly, although I don’t see that happening. “Good girl.”

His hand runs through my hair several times, relaxing me, and a second later, I jump again when I feel something brush against my lips.

I part them instinctively and feel Reid’s hard cock slip inside. It’s warm and firm, leaking salty pre-cum on my tongue, and I hum at the taste of it.

“Fuck, that’s hot,” Reid groans quietly as I work my tongue across the underside of his shaft and then circle his crown.

A hand finds my thigh and trails downward, all the way to my foot, but I can’t tell whose it is, not even when it starts massaging the sole. I groan around Reid’s cock, and he gently rocks his hips forward and back, guiding his length in and out of my mouth.

“Let’s play a little game,” he says as he continues fucking my mouth. “A guessing game. We’re going to take turns touching you or fucking you, and you’re going to try to figure out who it is.”

I draw back a little, popping off his shaft to speak. “What if I get it wrong?”

He just chuckles in response, his fingers tracing the line of my jaw. Then he kisses me before the mattress shifts as he moves to one side. I shiver as the hands massaging my foot set it gently back on the bed, and the mystery man moves upward over me.

A cock head presses against my entrance, and my hips instinctively rise to meet it.

Everythingfeels more powerful like this. Maybe it’s because I can’t see, so my body is trying to compensate, but I swear I canfeel each electric little movement as whoever it is starts to press inside me, opening me up. I can’t feel any piercings, so it’s safe to rule out Sebastian.

“Sebastian?” I guess in a whisper.

“Wrong,” Reid answers for whoever is fucking me, and when I open my mouth, another cock slides between my lips. He’s not gentle, hitting the back of my throat on the first thrust, and when I gag a little, he pulls back and strokes my cheek. “Too rough?”

“Not rough enough,” I gasp back, my body buzzing.

Reid chuckles. “That’s our filthy girl. Every time you get it wrong, you’ll pay for it.”

“Fuck,” I whimper.

“Oh, trust me, there will be fucking,” he promises, and whoever’s inside me takes a hard thrust out and in, making my breath catch in my throat.

God. If this is the punishment, I can’t wait to find out what the reward is.

---