Page 123 of The Very Naughty List

Suddenly filled with a fierce determination, I nudge Sebastian out of the way and bury my face in her pussy, my tongue driving into her. She shudders against my mouth, her fingers sliding through my hair.

“So good,” I groan. “We’re never letting you go, trouble. Never.”

Nick isn’t about to let me have her all to myself, so he pushes me out of the way and starts eating Hailey out like he’s afraid he’ll never get the chance again.

We keep passing her between the three of us, taking turns feasting on her and letting our bodies say all the things our words can’t express adequately. We share her just like we always have, one of us working her pussy while the others tongue herclit or play with her breasts, until she’s clawing at our hair and begging us with incoherent words.

“Please,” she gasps. “Please, I need to come. Oh god, I’m so close…”

Finally, Sebastian stands to kiss her mouth, holding her gently by the back of her head, while Nick flicks at and sucks on her clit, and I hungrily plunge my tongue in and out of her.

“Come for us,” I beg, needing to feel it. To remind myself that she’s still here, that she’s alive, and that this connection between us still burns just as bright as it always has. “For all of us. Right now.”

Her body starts to tremble, and her fingers dig into my scalp as she turns as rigid as a board and then shudders against my face. Nick keeps working her clit, and the gush of arousal that accompanies her climax soaks my lips and chin, turning me on even more as I fuck her with my tongue.

As the orgasm finally subsides, she slumps a bit, resting more of her weight against us. Nick leans back, and I carefully scoop her up into my arms and kiss her forehead repeatedly as she nuzzles against me.

“More,” she whispers, already sounding sleepy, and I chuckle.

“Not yet, baby. Fuck, I want nothing more than to carry you to bed to show you just how badly we all need you, but we don’t want to hurt you. You need time to recover first.”

“Okay.” She sighs, and the fact that she gave in so quickly lets me know that she really must be exhausted. “But… will you lie with me?” she asks, gazing up into my eyes.

I stroke her cheek and smile, my chest aching. “Of course we will, trouble. Always.”

She beams at me, and I carry her to the bedroom and lay her down like she’s the most precious jewel in the world.

The three of us help her get under the covers, then carefully climb into bed with her. I can’t keep my hands off her, so I pull her to my chest, where she rests her head against my shoulder and sighs contentedly. Sebastian presses his chest against her back, tenderly kissing down her neck and shoulder, while Nick sits at the edge of the bed and reaches under the covers for one of her feet to massage it.

Hailey’s gaze moves between us all, emotions roiling behind her eyes as she takes a deep breath.

“So this is… real?” she whispers. “We’re really doing this—the four of us, together? Are you in?”

“For as long as you’ll have us,” I say immediately, at the same time Sebastian answers, “Fuck, yes,” and Nick nods and grunts, “Definitely.”

All three of our voices blend into one, and tears shimmer in Hailey’s eyes as a shaky smile curves her lips.

“Good,” she whispers. “Because I’m in too.”

I grin back at her, my heart thudding against my ribs.

I swear, those are the best words I’ve ever heard in my life.

42

HAILEY

“I really can’t thankyou enough for everything you’ve done over the past few days,” I say, cradling my phone by my ear.

“Eh, it’s nothing.”

Lorelai laughs, casually downplaying her skills as a keyboard warrior who’s been coming to my defense in the comment threads of nearly all the social media channels where people have been talking about me online.

“Someone had to get on there and talk some sense into all these ignorant, backward fools,” she adds, indignation clear in her voice. “Whatever happened to open-mindedness? Besides, nobody trashes my bestie and gets away with it.”

A grimace twists my lips. “So… has it been really bad? Is it getting even worse?”

I haven’t allowed myself to look at any of it, choosing to preserve my peace and the happiness I’ve found with my men.

---