Page 101 of The Very Naughty List

“Good. Now lean forward,” Reid instructs, pressing gently on the small of my back.

I drop both hands on either side of Nick’s head to brace myself and present my ass to him. Reid kneels behind me, his chest pressed against my back, and teases my asshole with his fingers. My breath catches at the unfamiliar sensation, my body clenching involuntarily.

“Breathe deep now, trouble,” he tells me, his voice soothing. “Nice and deep, in and out.”

I do as I’m told, and Reid runs his fingers around and across my hole, slowly getting me used to the feeling of it and relaxing me while he kisses my neck and shoulder. Sebastian stands in front of me, his pierced cock bobbing in front of my face, and pops open the bottle of lube. Reid reaches out, and Sebastian turns the bottle over to drizzle out a healthy amount into Reid’s palm. Reid works it into his fingers to warm it up.

“Are you ready?” he asks as he lowers his hand back to my ass.

“Fuck yes,” I whimper, but my breath still catches when his slick fingers find my asshole again. My pussy clamps around Nick’s cock, pulling a groan out of him, but it’s nothingcompared to how tightly I squeeze him when one of Reid’s knuckles slips past the tight ring of muscles.

“Goddamn, you’re gonna make me come like this,” Nick groans as my pussy spasms around him.

“You’re gonna make me come first,” I say, shaking my head a little jerkily. I can feel sensations building inside me, pleasure already burning so hot in my veins that I know it won’t take long.

Hunger flashes in his irises, and his fingers dig into my hips like he can’t wait to start fucking me again. That makes two of us.

“That’s one finger,” Reid says as he pushes it all the way into me, then starts slowly dragging it back out. Both my holes squeeze, and I can’t fight the groan that bubbles at the back of my throat. “Keep breathing. I’m going to work another finger in.”

I take another deep, long inhale, and on the exhale, two of Reid’s fingers start pushing against my hole, making my toes curl. The stretching feels amazing, and with Nick’s firm cock still buried in me, it’s already almost enough to make me come. But Reid applies more pressure, shoving his thick fingers into me and opening me up more, and I know I’m going to lose it.

“Fuck, I can’t hold it,” I whimper and hold on to Nick’s shoulders as another orgasm tears through me. Reid’s fingers fuck me faster, working me through it as Nick thrusts up into me and I soak his cock in response.

“Good girl. Give in to it,” Reid encourages, twisting his fingers up to the knuckle inside me and making me cry out as wave after wave of pleasure pulses through me. I fall forward onto Nick, my elbows and wrists resting on his chest, and Reid chuckles. “I think you’re ready for the real deal now.”

“Shit,” I whisper as the last of the orgasm works its way out of me. But Sebastian tips my head up by my chin, his dribbling cock beckoning me, and I take it into my mouth without a second thought, working his piercings with my tongue.

“Oh, she’s definitely ready,” he says with a laugh as he passes Reid the bottle of lube. I hear the cap pop and the wet crackle as Reid coats his cock with it. His greased cock head finds my hole, teasing it, and I moan around Sebastian’s cock.

“Deep breaths now, trouble. Just like before,” Reid says, stroking my lower back as he starts pushing into me. My eyes flutter shut, but I keep breathing and bobbing on Sebastian as Reid stretches me out. His head presses past the tight ring of muscles a few seconds later, and the breath leaves my lungs, my cry muffled around Sebastian’s shaft.

It’s a good thing I have Sebastian’s cock in my mouth to keep me quiet, otherwise the whole neighborhood would hear me screaming in pleasure.

“Is that okay?” Reid asks, pausing. “How does it feel, trouble?”

I draw back a little so that I can speak, my voice raspy. “It feels… oh god, it’s so much. But I need… I need more.”

“That’s our girl.”

Reid keeps working his way inside, murmuring praise and encouragement as he tells me to open for him, to let him in, telling me he knows I can do it. Nick lies still to give me the chance to adjust, and after what feels like a long time, I hear Reid exhale in pleasure when the base of his cock meets my body.

“It’s in,” he rasps. “You’re taking all of me. All ofus. Are you all right?”

A moan is all I can manage to answer with, and the three of them chuckle. Reid stays still for a few moments before he starts to very slowly drag his cock out of me, and I feel like I might pass out from the sheer amount of pleasure rushing to my brain. But it’s nothing compared to the way every nerve ending in my body lights up when he starts driving back into me again.

“Fuck!” I hiss, Sebastian’s cock falling out of my mouth. But he lifts me by the chin and presses back in, muffling the rest of my noises.

“This is what you wanted, isn’t it, shortcake?” he asks as I hollow my cheeks around him.

And he’s so fucking right about that. This is every one of my filthiest fantasies come to life.

I’ve forgotten how to speak, all rational thought replaced by the wavelike rhythm of the three of their cocks sliding in and out of me in alternating movements, completely in sync. Sebastian slides down my throat while Reid thrusts into my ass and Nick draws out of my pussy.

It’s fucking ecstasy. The men murmur filthy things to me, punctuating their words with snaps of their hips, filling me up even more as the tempo increases.

Sebastian’s cock leaks precum onto my tongue, flooding my senses with the salty tang of him, and I hum in delight. His head drops back while his hands wrap around the back of my neck, holding me still so he can use my mouth at his own pace.

I’m completely lost in the thrill of it all—until somewhere across the room, my phone starts ringing in the clothes I left behind. I ignore it, too lost in the moment to care. But almost as soon as it stops ringing, it starts up again.

---