Page 90 of Better Hide

“Depends which hole.”

“No! Get that away from me.” I try to kick Cole, but he simply hops on the island and yanks my shorts the rest of the way off. He gets between my legs and holds up the spoon dramatically. “Hmmm.”

I struggle, but Jayden has my upper body pinned entirely.

“You’re lucky, I’ll do the small end. But only ‘cause the spoon is dirty and can’t have you getting an infection.” Cole turns the ladle over. “But this is too small for your pussy.”

“Cole, no.” Fear fills me. There’s no way I want the handle going anywhere near me.

Cole watches my reaction, his pupils getting bigger. “By all means, fight me, Jo. It’ll only make it more fun for us.” He glances behind me. “Jayden’s about to blow a load in his pants.”

Jayden growls, “Eyes to yourself.”

Cole slaps a mocking hand over his eyes while he brings the handle up to his mouth. He licks up it, getting it wet, and pops it in his mouth.

Fuck, fuck, fuck. He plans to fuck me with that.

Cole lowers the ladle to bump into my thigh, all while covering his eyes.

I stiffen. “Cole.”

He drags the ladle down to my pussy. I arch my hips. Maybe I can get him to slide it into my pussy instead of where I think he plans to put it.

Cole peeks out between his fingers, then goes back to dramatically covering his eyes.

“Stop being an idiot,” Jayden growls.

Cole throws me a wink under his hand, then takes his hand away and slides the handle down to my ass.

I pucker immediately. The handle isn’t huge, but it’s partially flat and oval-shaped.

“Cole, please.”

“Relax, Jo, and this won’t hurt as badly.”

Jayden leans down in my ear. “Are you begging, kitten?”

I try to thrash back and forth. Cole pauses, just brushing against my hole.

“You gonna beg me to stop, Jo?”

I stare at the handle. Cole is so hard his dick is throbbing.

“Will it help?” I grit my teeth.

“Hmmm.” He raises an eyebrow and smiles. “Why don’t you try it and see?”

I glare at him.

Cole pushes the handle roughly past the ring of muscle in my ass. I gasp, pain racing through me. My back arches off the island until Cole’s other hand grabs my waist and pushes me back down.

Jayden groans behind me, and Cole’s pupils are completely blown out. “What a fucking gorgeous sight.”

Cole pushes the handle deeper, and I scream.

“Jesus,” Jayden grunts.

“What a good girl. You’re doing so fucking well.” Cole lines his dick up with my pussy. “Be a good girl for me and take my dick too.”

---