Page 38 of My Favorite Sin

“This plan only serves your interest,” I say. “One time may be enough for you but I’m not ever getting over us.”

“You don’t know that.”

“I do.”

“Maybe once you’ve had me and the chase is over, you’ll…”

“I’ll what? Lose interest? Not going to happen.”

She sighs. “Dan, be reasonable about us. What do you expect for us, that we become a couple? No one would accept us. Our parents?—”

“I know. I feel guilt toward your mom, but I can’t livemy life to please her. I’ve stopped caring what other people will think. We can keep us a secret.”

“How? We nearly got caught kissing.”

She has an answer for everything. There’s always a reason as to why we can’t be together. No matter what I say, there’s no winning with this girl. She irritates the fuck out of me with her righteousness.

Fine. We’ll do this Ally’s way, but I won’t make it easy for her. She’ll suffer. I’ll break her down. Shewillbe mine. I won’t fucking let her get over me.

I glance back at her, keeping my calm. “You really think one time is enough for you?”

“I…” She swallows, nervous. “Yes. It has to be.”

It won’t be. But I can humor her. “I’ll agree to this on one condition. I get your first time.”

“Yes,” she says within an instant, not even thinking through my words.

Eager little virgin. So naïve. So eager to take my dick.

I slide my tongue along my teeth, staring out the windshield again. “It’s getting late. You should go inside. I have a long drive back to the city.”

“What?” she asks with a rude shock. “We’re not going to have sex right now?”

My mouth works hard to resist the smirk tugging at it. “I’m not fucking you in the backseat of my car.”

“When do you want to do it?”

“I haven’t decided yet. Not any time soon.”

“Dan—” she groans my name. “I have a date with Liam next Saturday.”

“I’ve given my one condition. If you’re not happy with it, you’re free to back out of the deal.”

“It would feel wrong seeing him when I’ve promised myself to someone else.”

“You two aren’t exclusive,” I point out. “Liam told you he’s available to other people. I’m sure he’s getting plenty of sex elsewhere. If he’s so into you, he’ll be happy to wait.”

“I’m trying to do the right thing and move on from you,” she argues.

Finally, I match her temperament, my voice low but harsh. “You leave me high and dry for Paris, then you leave me again tonight after begging me to kiss you. Now you’re asking me to sleep with you, not for the purpose of wanting me but to get over me?—”

“You know I want you?—”

“I’m not done talking. You’re a fucking brat, Ally. If you want me to get over you, a quickie in the back of my car isn’t the way to go. When the time comes, I’m going to enjoy your body for an entire day and night. I’m going to fuck you in every hole. Fill you with my cum till it’s dripping out of you. I am going to degrade the fuck out of your body with my dick and I won’t be gentle.”

A moan slips from Ally’s lips. Her eyes widen and her breath grows more audible. That’s my girl, turned on from my words despite not wanting to be. “My God, you’re infuriating,” she mutters, dropping her head.

“You don’t know the definition of infuriating, Ally.” I grab her chin, drawing her face toward mine. “I have a constant fucking hard-on from this whole good girl persona you show the world. The cute little dresses you wear. The pretty ribbons in your hair. Yet I’m the only one who knows beneath it all you just want to get fucked by your stepbrother. You’ve been hiding that side from me since returning to the country. I want to see the real you again. The needy girl who is a slut for me and only me.”

---