Page 34 of My Favorite Girl

Dan marvels over the display I’m giving him. “Look how hard you’re working. Clench your pussy like I taught you to.”

I focus on his instruction, squeezing myself around the dildo, moaning as I try to make my muscles as tight as possible.

“That’s it. Feel how much more intense the pleasure is when your pussy has a dick to grip onto?”

I nod desperately, unable to talk.

“Do you like this, Ally, being on display for me? Doing filthy things you know you shouldn’t?”

“Yes.” He knows me so well.

“Could you just imagine if someone walked in on you right now and saw what a good girl you’re being for your stepbrother?”

The pleasure of this toy is so much more intense than I ever expected. It’s powerful and all-consuming, but it’s Dan’s words that makes my pussy quiver and clench tighter around the shaft.

“Squeeze harder, Ally. Come for me.” Dan increases the vibrations yet again, sending me spiraling out of control.

I scream as my orgasm hits, my whole body trembling. Pleasure courses through me, leaving my senses reeling as I come harder than I ever have before. Dan presses another button, and I feel hot liquid spill inside me as the dildo ejaculates. Another cry leaves me, my muscles still contracting, refusing to let go of the pleasure that Dan has given me.

When the orgasm begins to ease, I pull away from the dildo, catching my breath on my hands and knees.

Dan’s whisper cuts through the silence. “You’d take the real thing so much better than that toy.”

Panting, I look up to find him approaching with slow steps. He crouches right in front of me, my skin heating all over again as he gently brushes my wet hair back from my forehead. He looks me over, studying my face with a tortured expression in his eyes. His finger hooks beneath my chin, tilting my face up to his.

“You’re so pretty when you come, Ally,” he whispers. “You’ve worked so hard. You must be exhausted. Let me clean you up.”

Dan takes my arms, lifting me to my feet. He turns the shower on, the water warm and comforting, and detaches the shower head, silently washing the sweat off my body like I’m royalty and he worships me. I watch him, dazed and tingling with bliss. I’m in a dream I never want to leave.

His gaze moves lower, between my legs, and his jaw hardens. I realize the fake cum is leaking out of me. “I wish it was real,” I murmur. “I wish it was yours. I wish we could be together. You’re all I want.”

Dan’s eyes return to mine, dark and pained. He doesn’t say anything, just takes a washcloth and wipes away the sticky liquid. He knows as well as I do that what I want can’t happen. I don’t let it ruin the moment.

In some sense, it truly does feel like Dan and I had sex tonight. Not physically, but he was in control of that toy and telling me how to use it. He’s the one who gave me pleasure. Itwas the most vulnerable and intimate I’ve ever been, and it was with him.

When the water is switched off, Dan grabs a towel and wraps me in it, drying my hair and body. I expect him to leave now that we’re done, like he did when teaching me how to touch myself, but he scoops me into his arms, cradling me like I’m a delicate doll, and carries me back to his bed.

Dan lays me beneath the covers, completely naked, then strips out of his own clothes, down to his boxers, and joins me in bed. He pulls me into his arms, his hard cock against my back, his hands cupping my breasts, and with his lips on the nape of my neck.

“This is all one-sided.” My eyelids are heavy with the call of sleep. “I want to see you without your clothes on. I want to see you come.Iwant to make you come.”

“Not tonight. Sleep, my queen,” he murmurs, his hot breath tickling my neck, his words giving me hope there’ll be a next time. And I do fall asleep, the most content I’ve ever been in my life.

Chapter 16

Dan

The same night, Friday, June 1

Mine

There’s no way I can fall asleep after what just happened between me and Ally in the bathroom. The things she lets me do to her…

Fuck.

I keep replaying the night in my mind as she sleeps tucked beneath my arm, where she belongs. The way she fucked that dildo, it was so raw and desperate. I can only imagine how she’d ride my cock. The sounds she made in that shower and the look on her face as she came… The memory will forever live in my head. I shouldn’t have let any of it happen, but I’m in too deep, too consumed by this girl to feel even the slightest bit of guilt anymore.

I stroke her wet hair and kiss her cheek, my gaze traveling down the length of her naked body and enjoying every inch of what I see, her skin tinged blue beneath my neon lamp. I need to jerk off to get rid of this raging hard-on I have, but there’s noway I can leave Ally’s side. Tonight, it feels like she’s truly mine, if only for a little while, and I won’t waste a minute of it.

---