Page 141 of Unforgettable

“I’m ready,” Josh croaked.

“Fuck. Yes, you are.” Reed’s voice was low and coated in lust. He positioned himself directly behind Josh, and I craved to see what was happening. I wanted to witness the first time Reed pushed inside Josh, but I wasn’t going to pass up having Josh inside me and watching his face contorted in pleasure.

Josh took a deep breath. He pressed forward, and his eyes closed. A low, manly sound emanated from the back of his throat while Reed murmured a long, muffled curse behind him. His cock twitched inside of me.

My hands ran down Josh’s sides, over the flexed muscles and soft skin, until I found the globes of his ass. My fingers brushed against Reed’s that were poised against his cheeks. We tangled our fingers together, and I squeezed and helped him spread Josh apart.

My eyes finally connected with Reed’s, and I watched his whiskey depths overflow with emotion and unhindered craving. A smile twitched at the corner of his mouth, and he threw his head back in ecstasy. The muscles in his neck flexed and his Adam’s apple bobbed with what I knew was restraint. He was trying, just as Josh was, to keep quiet against the new, overwhelming sensations overcoming them both.

“Holy shit.Move,” Josh groaned.

“Are you begging me to fuck you, Sunshine?”

Josh choked out a humorless laugh and lurched forward when Reed thrust into him. “I don’t beg,” Josh ground out.

“Oh, but I would love to hear it. Hear you beg for my cock, because you’re so fucking tight. You feel sogood.”

FORTY-SIX

Josh

My body was overcomewith more sensations than I ever thought imaginable.

Being buried deep inside Amanda’s tight, wet heat was always better than the time before, but it was only magnified by having Reed inside of me. There were a few minutes of uncomfortable pressure as I got used to his fingers, but the feeling quickly morphed into a craving for more.

Each of his movements was intentional—relaxing and preparing me for his cock. When I felt the slick crown breach my ass, there was a moment of fear that I couldn’t suppress. All of my concerns that I wouldn’t enjoy it weighed down on me, as did some of the world’s views of what we were doing. The label we’d both carry with the relationship and every other thought that would pull me out of the moment.

I closed my eyes against them and tried to focus on the good because there was so much of it. I needed it to outweigh the confusion buzzing through me, otherwise I knew I’d find myself imploding and taking two of the most important people in my life with me.

That’s when I felt Amanda’s hands run down my torso and tangle with Reed’s. Together they spread me wide to welcome his cock. My eyes snapped open, and in Amanda’s ocean blues, all I saw was awe and unyielding hunger.

All of my anxiety vanished with that one look. Because the three of us were all that mattered. I wasn’t completely ignorant to believe that it wouldn’t happen again—when we announced to the world our relationship, I knew we would likely face hatred and ignorance.

But that wasn’t what I was focused on at that moment. I was focused on the woman beneath me and the man behind me. And how together, they were everything I never knew I needed.

“Holy shit.Move,” I groaned.

“Are you begging me to fuck you, Sunshine?”

I laughed and lurched forward when Reed thrust into me.Fuck, he was big. “I don’t beg,” I panted through clenched teeth. But even as I said it, I knew I likely would have. Had he not begun moving in slow, even thrusts, I would have likely begun pleading that he do so.

“Oh, but I would love to hear it. Hear you beg for my cock, because you’re so fucking tight. You feel sogood.” Listening to Reed come undone by the pleasure he was taking from my body was a huge turn-on. As was the feel of his pointedly masculine hands running over the planes of my back and gripping my hips. I loved the sensation of his calloused palms and the hair of his legs brushing against mine as much as I did Amanda’s smooth softness.

He picked up his pace, and I timed my thrusts with Reed’s, pushing into Amanda as he did the same to me.

“How does it feel?” Amanda hesitantly asked, running a hand down my face as the other continued to grasp my ass. Reed’s hands maintained a punishing grip on my hips, and each time he pushed in and out, the tip of him slid deliciously across that spot he’d found only weeks ago. With each pass, and as Amanda tightened around me, I knew I was going to come embarrassingly quick.

“So fucking good. Better than I imagined.” Each word was more difficult than the last to get out.

Amanda gasped, and I pounded into her harder, snaking my hand between us to find her swollen clit. Her wetness coated the inside of her thighs and mine, and I drew my thumb in quick circles until she bucked off the bed.

“Yes, fuck her good and hard. Make her come while I watch my cock disappear into your tight ass. Are you going to come for us, Cielo?”

She nodded frantically. A light sheen of sweat covered her skin, and I bent lower to lick at the salty sweetness. My tongue traveled between her breasts and up her neck.

We were trying to be quiet, but if anyone else was still awake, there was no doubt they’d likely hear us. Reed’s hips snapped forward at a punishing pace, his cock slipping in and out of my ass with ease as I met his pace between Amanda’s thighs.

The walls of her cunt tightened, and there was a flood of heat and wetness. My mouth suctioned over hers a split second before she cried out. I hungrily swallowed each of her sweet sounds, and I wished I could hear and bask in each of the noises she made from the pleasure we stripped from her body.

---