Page 158 of Plaything

I disagreed with his timing, but I admit, I was having my own fun watching the desperate pouts she tried to hide from us. She was so fucking adorable; it was hard not to give in to her. If she looked up at me with those big blue eyes that were pleading with me to fuck her again, I might just give in.

“The poor thing is probably exhausted,” Aiden smirked. “If she wasn’t acting like such a spoiled brat, I would probably pity her.”

I huffed a laugh. I bet her every thought consisted of getting the absolute shit railed out of her. She was far too shy to try to tempt us with words. Her last attempt was, ‘I’m bored.’ We all knew what she meant, but she never told us what she really wanted. I thought her shyness was sexy, but another part of me wanted to corrupt her into saying all the dirty things she wanted us to do to her.

She shifted in her sleep, clinging closer to Niko. Her small fist was balled in his shirt, her raven hair in wild waves over her shoulders. I’d never get over how pretty she was. My work was forgotten as I cannily allowed my eyes to feast on her.

Her desperation was laughable. She hated being cold, yet there she lay, scarcely clothed in slutty shorts and a top that exposed her arms, back, and stomach. Goosebumps covered her skin, and her nipples hardened against the sheer top. The little vixen wasn’t even wearing a bra. My mouth watered, and I longed to lick and suck the sensitive peaks.

My cock twitched and strained against my jeans. For what seemed like the millionth time, I lifted my hips to adjust myself.

“Having a hard time over there, Wyatt?” Niko teased.

“I’m good,” I lied. All I could think about was her ass. With her leg on top of Niko and the other sticking straight onto the leg rest, I had the tempting view of where her shorts dipped down by her pussy. She was wet—the shorts clung to her and perfectly outlined her cunt. No panties, either?

It would be so easy to push them to the side and tease her tight little hole. Fuck. “Are we really waiting until tomorrow?” I asked, letting my annoyance show.

Aiden laughed at me. “Way to stay strong, man,” he sarcastically shook a fist in the air.

Niko tilted his head, angling himself so he could see her ass. He ran his hand along her lower back before caressing her exposed ass. “Hmm, does it count as touching if she’s asleep?” He cocked a mischievous brow.

That son of a bitch. I grinned while shaking my head at him. On one hand, she’d never know that we broke our own rules. On the other... we would be giving in. “It definitely counts, but what she doesn’t know won’t hurt her,” I answered. She’d already consented to us playing and fucking her when she was asleep. Given her state, I don’t think she’d mind.

“She’ll wake up,” Dominic assured.

Niko’s hand traveled further down her ass until he ran a finger along the damp divot of her shorts. “Maybe if you tried,” Niko shot. “I’ve got a very gentle touch,” he gloated.

I hated to admit it, but he wasn’t lying. Dominic wasn’t gentle in any aspect of his life, nor was Aiden. I could be, but sometimes something else entirely took over, and gentleness wasn’t even in my repertoire—I had no control over it. Even now, if I were in Niko’s position, I wouldn’t be able to stop myself from jamming two of my fingers knuckle-deep into her.

He was playing a risky game, but I fully supported it. She’d been unjustly subjected to an unfair punishment after already being edged. Even if she wouldn’t remember, I was sure she’d wake up with less of an attitude.

Slowly stroking her slit over her shorts, I watched his finger glisten in her arousal. Poor baby... She was drenched. My cock twitched at the sight of her liquid desperation.

Even if I tried, I couldn’t look away as she shifted her hips, squirming in her sleep. I didn’t have to look up to know my friends were also watching—it was impossible not to. Fuck, I loved it when she squirmed.

His touch was soft, barely putting any real pressure as he teased her. Every time he dipped his finger into the puddle, her legs twitched. The softest, sweetest whimper left her unconscious lips.

Niko’s every move was calculated, his eyes flickering between her pussy and her face, looking for any sign that she was waking up. I didn’t possess that kind of patience. Even sitting here watching, I felt the urge to get it over with and bury myself in her, not caring if she woke.

Cautiously, he hooked a finger around her shorts and pulled them to the side. I sucked in a silent breath, basking in the view of her perfect pussy. Her arousal was spread across her lips and clit, pooling out of her like a dam that broke.

My cock painfully longed for her, straining uncomfortably against my thigh.

Pink ankle socks covered her feet, and I watched her toes curl and flex as Niko smoothly stuck his middle finger inside her. He curled his finger towards her spine, caressing and teasing her walls.

The only sounds in the quiet house were the crackling of the fire, the patter of rain against the house, and her sloppy pussy. She’d release a moan or quiet cry every few seconds as Niko worked her body like a puppet, forcing an orgasm out of her.

Her thighs flexed as she tried to squeeze her legs shut. Niko’s body was keeping her from doing so. It was intoxicating to see her body’s natural reaction to him. I’d be replaying this over and over in my mind forever.

She began to squirm more, arching her ass back onto his hand. I expected him to move more to finish her off, but his movements stopped. He turned his head, studying her face.

I smirked. The cocky side of me wanted her to wake up just to see him fail. He was arrogant and overconfident; it would definitely humble him. He didn’t look away from her, but Aiden, Dominic, and I shared an eager glance, silently praying for his downfall.

Her legs stopped rustling, and she nestled her head back into his chest. Unfortunately, she was still sound asleep. Damn, I really thought she’d wake up to find his finger stilled inside her.

“There’s no way,” Aiden rolled his eyes, leaning his elbows on his knees and watching her face as he and Dominic had a better view than me. Well, I had the best view, just not of her face. If she was pretending to be asleep (which she wasn’t), Aiden would be able to tell, and her punishment would probably get extended.

Niko waited another minute before he moved again, continuing where he left off. His finger was slowly penetrating her, curling the single digit each time he was knuckle deep.

---