Page 43 of Plaything

...

Say it again.

My belly swarmed with butterflies at the words. I would do anything to hear any of them call me a good girl again. Maybe it was my lack of recognition, but I loved that he said that to me.

Niko grabbed my hand, gently pulling me with him. “Say goodnight,” he instructed, the rasp in his voice, making my panties wet.

I turned my head, seeing Aiden’s flashlight shine as he walked up the steps. It illuminated the hall enough for me to make out Dominic and Wyatt’s features.

Wyatt’s face shocked me and sent a wave of shivers through my body. His head was tilted down, and his blonde hair gently fell over his eyes in a way that darkened his features. Instead of his usual kind, pleasant expression, there was an obvious lust, a desperate hunger, that made him look absolutely feral.

Dominic’s eyes were locked on my ass, as it was very visible through the sheer shorts and cheeky panties. He smirked, his eyes flickering to my face when he felt me staring. He quickly looked behind me at Niko before cocking an eyebrow at me, almost in a challenging way.

Niko and I were in his doorway, about to close the door behind us, when Aiden reached the top of the steps. “Odette,” he began the second his eyes landed on Niko and me, hands interlocked, entering his dark room. He shined the light on the floor as he walked, a questioning expression on his face. “Are you sleeping with Niko?” He asked, no judgment in his tone.

I nodded. “Yes.”

His expression suddenly turned into an approving and slightly eager one. “So you’ve made your decision then?” He concluded.

I raised my eyebrows at his bluntness. I wouldn’t have accepted Niko’s’ offer to sleep with him in his bed unless I was really going to go through with being with them. That would just lead him and the others on, and I wouldn’t do that. My decision was made the second I stepped foot into this house. Aiden was clever; he analyzed even the tiny things.

Saying yes didn’t seem like it was enough. Along with the lust and attraction, there were affection and actual feelings that made up my desire for them.

“I’m yours.”

I made sure to look at each of them as I said the words. Niko held my hand tighter, still standing behind me. Aiden’s eyes softened, like years of waiting lifted off his shoulders. Wyatt was smiling again, although there was a pronounced bulge in his loose boxers that I was fighting not to look at.

Be polite. I was sure he didn’t want to draw attention to his... his... Maybe just a peak. No!

Dominic interrupted my polluted thoughts, his eyes narrowed at me, “Yes, you are,” he agreed.

Niko wrapped his arms around my stomach, pulling me to his front. “Good, because there’s no way I’m letting you go,” he smirked against my shoulder, where he rested his head.

I giggled, his hot breath tickling my neck. An intrusive thought crept into my mind. Eventually, we were going to have sex. That was wonderful, and I was looking forward to it, but they’d been with other people—I hadn’t. There were four of them, that was a lot of chances to catch something. “I just have one condition,” I started, feeling slightly embarrassed to ask this of them, but it was the only way I’d be comfortable.

Wyatt looked concerned. “Condition?” He repeated. “Name it,” he chuckled like he’d do whatever I asked.

I bit my lip. “Don’t take offense to this because I really don’t mean anything by it,” I buffered, choosing my words carefully. “You’ve all obviously been with other people, and I hate to even ask this of you—”

“We’ll get tested,” Aiden interrupted an amused grin on his lips. “That’s not offensive, Odette. You have every right to ask that of us,” he comforted.

My shoulders relaxed. “Thank you,” I said softly. “I can get tested too, but unless I sat on a really icky toilet seat or something...” I cringed.

Niko chuckled. “I don’t think that’s necessary, Cariño,” he dismissed. “Besides, it’s going to be some time before we have to worry about that,” he insisted.

I pushed my eyebrows together, not understanding what he meant. The sooner, the better; I’d been deprived for long enough. Being around them was torture in itself. They were unfairly handsome and had bodies I wanted to take a bite out of; they were so yummy. They’d obviously been eager, too; they couldn’t keep their hands off me.

Niko tilted his head, dipping his head into the crook of my neck. His lips traced along my skin behind my ear. “Virgins are so fun to play with,” he whispered against my skin, making arousal flood straight into my panties.

I looked straight at Aiden as Niko’s tongue made a wet trail on my skin. My eyes fluttered, and my pussy clenched, a dull, needy ache settling between my thighs. “Play?” I repeated. My attempt to keep my voice casual failed as it came out in a distracted whimper. All I could think about was his mouth against a very sensitive part of my neck.

Aiden, Wyatt, and Dominic all smirked, watching my useless body react to Niko’s’ seductions. If melting into the floor was possible, I would be reduced to a puddle.

The effect their touch had on me made me feel like a puppet under their control. They knew I was putty in their hands as soon as that switch was flipped and I was turned on.

Niko smirked against my neck. “Mhm,” he hummed. “It’s so easy to make you squirm,” he rasped. “I’ve barely done anything, and your legs are clenched,” he chuckled.

A deep blush stained my cheeks, realizing the force I was pushing my legs together. I sucked in a breath, unable to deny anything with four pairs of intense eyes on me.

---