Page 56 of Lie for a Lie

Now, I am questioning everything I have ever known about love. I have never longed for someone else’s girlfriend before, and part of me is fighting the idea of this being some sort of revenge or payback. I look toward Chris in the kitchen, whose eyes are fixed on me. I know he can see how much I want this woman all over my face.

Seth’s arms wrapping around her waist catches my attention before lifting her to him, clearly establishing his dominance. His eyes meet mine, and I take the full view of Paige’s now-exposed lace panties. The skirt is even shorter than I realize. I don’t bother hiding the desire as I linger on the piece of black lace and the curves of her ass cheeks barely peeking out.

Fury ignites in Seth’s eyes before he kisses Paige passionately and carries her back toward her bedroom. Whispering to her loud enough for me to hear.

“Let me show you how sorry I am for being late.”

Paige’s playful laugh is an arrow through my heart as they disappear down the hall.

I hear Chris’s voice, “She is so out of his league.”

I let out a soft laugh before looking back toward Chris.

“Would Bre be willing to meet us at the theater instead?”

Letting the silent plea show in my eyes. Chris nods, and we walk towards the door as soft moans of pleasure fill the suddenly way too-tiny condo.

Chapter 28

Paige

Fucking is what I call what happened last night. Once we close the bedroom door shut behind us; every kiss and thrust is claiming. His words are sinfully possessive.

I came almost immediately when he pinned me against the wall, fucking me with knee-high boots still on, and drove deeper than ever before. He looked into my eyes softly and whispered I love you before pulling out and having me drop to my knees to swallow his release. As far as dinner dates go, waking up with a pleasant ache between my thighs was all this girl really needs.

I roll over to where Seth has been sleeping, which is empty, and a piece of paper is on the pillow. I pull it towards me, lying flat on my back.

I went to grab some breakfast. Be back soon.

Seth.

I lay the note down on my rumbling stomach and smile.

Calm.

Safe.

Loved.

In the rare moment of peace, I drift back to sleep, remembering when Seth bent me over my bed last night.

I feel soft, gentle kisses on my shoulder and the warmth of a body pressing against my back. His needy cock, clearly interested as his lips find my neck. His fingers slowly teased me between my thighs. A small moan escapes my lips.

“Graham.”

He gently grazes my ear with his teeth, and I reach behind me, gripping his rigid cock firmly.

“I want you, Paige.”

He whispers in my ear as his hand rests between my thighs. I moan at his words and begin to firmly stroke his cock. He bites my shoulder, and I moan again, pumping him faster as his finger slides into my soaked pussy.

I shoot straight up in bed. Confusion and a need for release flood my senses. I am so turned on that a slight touch would make me erupt. I try to even out my breath and close my eyes.

A dream! A very real and intense dream.

Guilt begins to sit heavy in my gut. I’m unsure how I feel about wanting Graham more than I have ever wanted Seth. I throw my sheets off and head toward the bathroom, splashing my face with cold water before quickly using the restroom. I need a shower but will settle for a sexy one with Seth instead.

I grab Seth’s undershirt off the floor and pull it over my naked body. His natural scent lingers, and I pull a piece of the shirt towards my nose and inhale deeply. My lashes flutter in lust as I attempt to erase the thought of Graham’s cock as I hear my door open.

---