Page 79 of The Secrets of a Sin

“Arsen Hale. Charlotte’s boyfriend.” I add extra emphasis on the boyfriend, which only aggravates her further.

“I know who you are.” She spits while rolling her eyes in the process. “She’s just never mentioned anything about the two of you before.”

“She has no reason to. What pertains to us isn’t any of your business.”

Only just a minute into meeting Annalise, I could tell there was something off about her. With her extremely light hair, porcelain skin, and ocean blue eyes, she appeared innocent from the outside. Harmless and naïve. I would have mistaken her for a teacher's pet, but the second she opened her mouth, I couldn’t have been more wrong.

“It is my business when you decide you’re done fucking her and break her heart.”

Rage explodes within me, but I can’t let some fucking seventeen-year-old freak get to me. She knew absolutely nothing about me, but I was damn curious to know about her. I was interested in all three of them, to be exact, and their connection with Phoebe. So, shoving both hands into my pocket, I counter calmly.

“I just started fucking her, and I don’t plan on stopping anytime soon, or ever, for that matter.”

My words seem to set her off even more with the mention of me fucking Charlotte, but her solid stance doesn’t change. “And what happens when a new, fresh, tighter pussy comes along?” Her tone drops insignificantly. “Still think you can manage to stay faithful?”

Taking a small step towards her, I scan over her once more, watching as her frame tenses and eyes darken. “Your description sounds a lot like Charlotte.” I proclaim sternly. “If you only knew just how tight her cunt squeezes my cock, you’d understand why I don’t need anyone else.”

Her throat contracts instantly as her eyes shift back and forth from irate to curiosity.

Was she jealous of me? Is that why she’s being a bitch?

I study her closely, hoping to notice any more evidence of resentment, and it finally clicks when she shakes her head profusely. She didn’t just want to be her friend. She wanted to be in my position. She wanted to be the one fucking Charlotte.

“Do you always speak so crudely of your girlfriend? I’m sure she’d love to hear that you’re telling random people about her pussy.”

I couldn’t even concentrate on the words that were spewing out of her mouth because all I could imagine was breaking this girl's neck. I didn’t care that she was a woman, all I could see was a threat.

Taking another step towards the small blonde, I can feel my hands shaking with the need to frighten her. To latch around her frail neck and warn her to stay away from Charlotte.

I wanted to warn all three fucking girls.

“I thought you two were best friends?” I question as my gaze pierces through her. “Surely you’d know she loves all things nefarious. In fact, you’d be surprised with just how brazen she can be once I let her get my cock out.” I lower my voice just enough for her to hear me. “She can’t get enough of me.”

Her jaw ticks, but other than that, she doesn’t give me the reaction I was expecting. Instead, her mouth lifts into a devious half-smile.

“Trust me. I know just how bold she can be, Arsen.” She runs her eyes across my face. “Normal girls don’t just finger themselves when they catch two of their friends fucking in the showers.” Removing her hands from her hips, she widens her mouth slightly as her tongue drags along her teeth. “I’m just surprised she didn’t stay long enough to come.”

The fuck did she just say to me?

My anger alters into a blazing rage as she continues trying to provoke me. And unfortunately, she was getting to me. She wasn’t the only one jealous. I was fucking furious at the thought of Charlotte even touching this chick, let alone desiring to be with her. It made every bone and muscle in my body spasm in pain as her words sunk deep into my head. Was what she said true? Or was she trying to fuck with my head?

“What the fuck are you doing here anyway at five in the morning?” I growl, wishing that I had locked Charlotte’s door on the way out, so she doesn’t just take it upon herself to walk inside unwelcome.

Another nasty smirk forms as she realizes she got me. “What pertains to Charlotte and me is none of your damn business.” She uses the same words that I used on her, and I immediately close the distance between us.

“What the hell are you trying to do?” I bark. “Because if you want to play games with me, just know that I always win. I’ll get the girl.” I grind out. “And I’ll get the satisfaction knowing you’ll never be able to have her like I do.”

“What makes you so sure that I haven’t already had her?” She suggests as my chest heaves violently and the blood vessels in my hand threaten to explode.

“Because the only person she wants and needs is me. I fulfill all her desires while you would only scratch the surface. She wants cock, Annalise.” I snarl directly into her face, hoping to frighten her. “She wants to be filled and corrupted by a man. So unfortunately for you, pussy will never be on her menu.”

She lashes out immediately, jabbing a finger into my chest. She presses hard until I swiftly remove it. “You're a pig.” She spits, disgusted. “You don’t think I could give her the same amount of pleasure you can? You don’t think I could fill her and make her come like you?” She shouts as her hand moves around spastically in the air around her. “Women can do exactly what men can, perhaps even better. And if I knew any better, your girlfriend seemed to have been extremely curious about the way my pussy ground onto another.” Her eyes flash to mine. “So be careful, Arsen. I may have to show her what it's like to be corrupted by a woman.”

Before I do something really fucking stupid, I start to walk past her. I needed to breathe. I needed to calm the hell down and get out of this school.

“Aw, come back.” Annalise shouts down the hallway. “I was starting to like having another Hale around.”

I come to a stop. My feet screech across the floor, and I instantly spin around.

---