Page 119 of Pretend Girlfriend

“Me too!” Theo exclaimed underneath me.

“I’m coming, oh fuck, oh God!”

I cried out with him, and Theo’s voice joined in as I felt his cock gushing into my pussy at the same time.

“I’m coming in your ass!” Austin screamed in pleasure.

Everything overwhelmed me: their twin dicks pistoning into me, my fingers on my clit, their hands holding onto me for dear life, their voices, the words describing the taboo act that wasn’t just a dream, it was actually happening, his cock was in my ass, filling me with his come. My orgasm was a physical thing, choking the air from my lungs and brightening my vision, until everything disappeared and only ecstasy remained.

49

Theo

“So,” Joanna said while the three of us laid on our backs in bed, side by side. “That just happened.”

“Did it?” Austin asked, his Texas twang more pronounced than usual. “I kinda figured it was a dream.”

“You dream about coming in a woman’s ass very often?” Joanna asked.

Austin shook his head. “Nope. But after tonight? It might just turn into a recurring dream. Like the dream where I show up for a test I didn’t study for. I get that one a lot.”

“I’m always on stage at the school talent show, naked,” I chimed in.

“That one’s never fun,” Austin agreed.

“The sex one is much better,” Joanna purred, stretching like a cat. “Hopefully you get that one a lot more often.”

It all felt so surreal. Two days ago, Joanna and I had playfully discussed having a threesome. It felt so abstract at the time, an idea rather than a real possibility. And then, as if we had manifested the desire out into the universe, Austin pretty much invited himself to join in tonight.

I’ll admit: the idea of him watching us kind of weirded me out at first. I wasn’t a porn star. The thought of someone else’s eyes on me while I performed in bed was, frankly, terrifying. All of my sex moves were made with the woman’s pleasure in mind—which was not the same thing as looking good to a third party. What if I looked totally stupid?

But hell, I liked trying new things. Especially if it involved a sexy woman like Joanna. And when we started making out on the couch, and she went down on me while Austin watched?

It was hotter than I expected.

A lot hotter.

Like, hot enough to make me come within a minute.

I knew there were people out there who enjoyed watching others have sex, and some that loved being watched. Exhibitionism and voyeurism. Was I really into that, too? I’d never expected to be, but I couldn’t argue with the results of the evening.

And the best part was how much Joanna loved it. It turned me on seeing her so excited, which probably fed into her enjoyment of it, a kick-ass feedback loop of pleasure. I was exhausted from coming twice in quick succession, but I was already fantasizing about doing it again.

“Now that it’s over, how was your first threesome?” I asked.

“Amazing,” she sighed happily, turning to cuddle against my body. “Better than I ever imagined it would be. You?”

“Did you see how hard I came?” I asked. “It exceeded all of my expectations.”

“It was y’all’s first threesome?” Austin asked. “Mine too. And yes, I damn well enjoyed it.”

“Cheers to all of us,” I said, holding up my palm. Austin high-fived me, then Joanna.

“I had a lot of firsts,” Joanna added. “I’ve never done anything with my… you know.”

“Your ass?” I asked.

“It feels so naughty just talking about it!” she said.

---