Page 118 of Pretend Girlfriend

Austin pulled me upright and used his free hand to twist my face around so he could kiss me. His lips were warm and tasted like rum, and his unique scent filled my nostrils.

I’m kissing Austin, the thought floated across my mind. While the two of them…

I moved harder and faster on Theo, like I was riding a bucking bronco. Austin was still pumping in my ass, and thrusting his cock forward in my grasp, reminding me of what he wanted. The stimulation was intense, and complex, and exactly what I wanted. I stopped caring about all the problems in my life and focused only on the two men wedged on either side of me.

Then Austin slowly removed his fingers, and grabbed the butt plug from the bed. I was close to another climax, and the thought of the toy inside me—so much bigger than just his fingers—gave me pause. Austin added some lube to the black plug, then guided it down between my cheeks.

I didn’t want an inanimate object inside me. I wanted more. Austin’s fingers felt amazing because it was a part of him, and that’s what gave me my next idea. An idea which terrified me as much as it thrilled me.

Do it, I told myself. Don’t think. Just do it.

I grabbed the plug with my hand, wrapping my fingers around it until I was coated with lube. Then I tossed it aside and reached for Austin’s hard length again, stroking him until he was completely slick.

“Not interested in the toy anymore?” he asked.

I shook my head innocently.

“It’s awfully big,” Austin said.

“Nothing wrong with taking it slow,” Theo agreed.

But that’s not what I meant. And I took immense pleasure in the fact that I was about to surprise both of them.

I guided Austin’s cock up against my asshole. Even that was enough to make me shiver with excitement, feeling his head up against my tight little ring. He gasped when he realized what I intended.

“Are you sure you can…” Austin said.

I bit my lip and nodded over my shoulder. “I’m going to tease you first. Tell me when you’re close.”

I pressed his cock up against my ass, stroking him faster while riding Theo. It felt a bit like walking to the edge of the diving board, but being too scared to take the plunge. I wanted it, I really did. But I’d never done this before. Hell, up until a minute ago I’d never had anything put up there.

But that’s what made it so exciting.

I began moaning, and reached down to rub my clit while I drove my hips down against Theo. He was squeezing my ass with both hands, still spreading me wide for Austin’s rock-hard cock. Up and down the tip went, grinding against my rear entrance. Teasing everyone involved, heightening the tension.

And then, when I couldn’t take it anymore, Austin said the words I was hoping to hear: “I’m close.”

I moved faster on Theo, impaling myself down on his cock so hard the skin on our thighs slapped together. Austin was starting to groan, music to my ears, and I decided: what the hell.

I pulled him toward me, shoving my ass back at the same time, and the tip of his cock pushed into my ass.

“Ohh!” all three of us moaned at the exact same time. Theo must have been able to feel Austin inside of me, because his eyes widened and his mouth hung open in bliss.

“Oh my God,” Austin groaned loudly. “You know where my cock is?”

“Mmm hmm,” I replied.

“Say it,” he demanded. “Tell me where it is.”

“It’s. In. My. Ass,” I gritted out.

It was all too much. I started to come, small waves of pleasure at first which built into more massive walls of ecstasy, crashing into me and electrifying my entire body. Austin was thrusting forward a little, the tip of his cock going in and out of my ass while I twitched and shuddered on Theo.

“Fuck me,” I begged. “Fuck my ass.”

“That’s what I wanted to hear,” Austin drawled into my ear, biting the lobe and grabbing me by the waist. The sensation was amazing: two hands on my ass, two on my waist, and two cocks thrusting into me. Austin held himself back, only pushing inside by an inch at most, but it was just enough. It was everything.

“I’m gonna come,” he growled. “Joanna, I’m… I’m…”