Page 111 of Foreplay on Words

“But I don’t know what I’m doing.” My heart beat harder at the thought of going through with this. I didn’t want to hurt her, but I also really wanted to try it.

“Then I guess it’s a good thing I don’t know either. We can learn together,” she giggled.

My hand rubbed up and down her thigh, as she continued to get me hard. “Shouldn’t we research this before we...”

“No, Evan...geez,” she laughed at my need to be fully prepared for something new. “Do you have lube?”

I nodded and reached over to the nightstand, pulling out a small bottle of lubricant.

“Go ahead. I’ve heard lube is your friend if you’re planning on me enjoying this.” She nodded at the bottle. I flipped open the cap and squirted some on myself, her hand sliding easier with the added moisture. I coated the tips of my pointer and middle fingers before I dropped the bottle.

She moved her leg from my chest and loosely wrapped it around my hip as I reached full mast. I scooted back and tilted her hips up with my free hand. My breathing picked up as she licked her lips, nodding at me.

Chase moaned lowly as I lightly ran my fingers along her skin. “It’s okay. This is going to be different for both of us. I’ll tell you if you need to stop.”

I pushed the tip of one finger into her ass, and she flinched a little, closing her eyes. My finger retreated, and I waited until her eyes opened again to try again.

“I’m fine. Keep going.” She grabbed my wrist and pulled my hand back toward her. My finger slipped further, and I slowly twisted it as I pulled back. “It’s just…alot.”

“Are you okay?”

Chase held her breath every time I pushed inside, but I couldn’t tell from the look of concentration on her face if she was enjoying it.

“I’m... I’m good,” she panted as she shifted her hips from side to side.

Her muscles relaxed slightly as I continued to open her up. It was definitely a different sensation. More concentrated pressure where she constricted my finger. Going slow seemed to be helping her relax, her hips shifting into my movements as the minutes ticked by.

“Are you ready?” she whispered as I pulled my fingers out. Nodding, I watched as she opened the lube again, squirting some on my fully engorged head. “Just go slow.”

“I should be asking you if you’re ready. It’s pretty obvious when I’m ready to go. But I don’t want to hurt you.”

She gave a jerky nod in response, and I grasped my cock in one hand, guiding the tip against her. She gasped as I pressed it into her tight hole and shifted into my movement. Her hips jumped as the head started to disappear inside.

“Fuck,” I panted as I stilled and let both of us adjust to the sensation. It was tighter. Much, much tighter. I couldn’t imagine what it felt like for her. Maybe we should have done something more to prepare her for this.

“Keep going,” she encouraged.

I exhaled a few shaky breaths as I pushed further, feeling the resistance of her tense muscles.

“Touch yourself,” I moaned as I tried not to lose it; she was so tight.

She nodded and licked her fingers, bringing them down to her clit and starting to circle slowly. After a few moments, I felt her relax, and I slipped in a little further. As I pulled back out slightly, she hissed.

“Go. Just keep going.” She wiggled her hips, and I slid back inside her ass. “It’s not bad, it’s just—”

She squealed and pushed one hand against my chest as I did what I was told. I tried to retreat, but her eyes locked with mine. “Just go slow. I’ll adjust.”

I nodded and gripped her hips, slowly thrusting with shallow movements.

“Shit,” I groaned as I watched the speed of her fingers increase, her neck flushing as I watched her pleasure start to crest.

Chase moaned again as I continued to keep my motions shallow, speeding slightly as I felt her relax.

“I’m gonna come.” Her fingers pressed hard on her clit as she rubbed faster. Her breasts were flushed red, and I was in awe as I watched myself slide in and out of her. I could feel her muscles clench as my heart practically beat out of my chest.

“Fuck, baby. That’s so hot,” I groaned as her hips stiffened, and I watched her pussy pulse rhythmically. Once she started to let go, I couldn’t hold on anymore and slipped out, cumming all over the sheets as she arched against them, moaning.

Resting my forehead on the arm braced against the headboard, I panted as I looked down at her. “You alright? That was fucking intense.” And I wanted to try it again when we’d had more practice.

---