Page 11 of A Sister's Secret

With a final look around the room that held so much of his former life, Oliver Thompson braced himself for the journey ahead. The determination in his eyes was clear, the line of his jaw set. There were answers out there, scattered like breadcrumbs through the forest of the past, and he would follow them until they led him to the clarity he sought—the clarity his sister deserved. Satisfied with his decision yet troubled by the grief, he poured himself a glass of whiskey to calm his nerves. When that glass was gone, he poured himself another one.

Chapter Five

The rustic scent of aged paper and wood shavings mingled in the air of the dimly lit workshop. Oliver, his rugged hands now still, sat amidst a chaos of memories splayed across his heavy oak desk. The glow of a solitary desk lamp cast elongated shadows as he leaned closer to scrutinize an old photograph—a Polaroid image of his sister laughing, her eyes bright with life. He traced the edges of the picture with a calloused fingertip as if trying to reach through time itself. In the box next to him were hundreds of other photos from their childhood, along with all of Michelle’s old things, which his parents allowed him to go through in his search for answers.

"Oliver?" Lisa's voice, warm and laced with worry, cut through the silence. She stood at the threshold, leaning slightly against the door frame, her figure soft yet resilient, like the light from the hallway that battled the room's gloom. Her eyes, usually so full of warmth, now held a storm of concern as she watched her husband lose himself in his search for answers.

"Hey," Oliver replied, not looking up, his voice barely more than a whisper lost among the whispers of the past.

"The kids are in bed," she said, tentatively stepping into the workshop. It wasn't just a place of crafting and creation; it had become a sanctuary for Oliver's grief, a refuge where he could chase the ghosts that haunted him. You've been here since dinner… Maybe it's time to rest?" Her suggestion hung between them, delicate and fragile.

Oliver's gaze remained fixed on the pictures, his jaw set, the muscles twitching as he wrestled with unseen adversaries. He had talked to more than a dozen of her old childhood friends and acquaintances these past few weeks, and no one could tell him anything about where she went or even why she left. It was a mystery to all and a surprise when it happened. She was simply just gone, they said.

"I can't, Lisa. There's something here, something we all missed. I need to find it."

Lisa moved closer, her presence a gentle force in the room, strong enough to stand against the tides of despair that threatened to consume him.

"I know you want to understand what happened to her, but this—" She gestured to the disarray of his makeshift investigation, "—this isn't healthy. It’s been weeks now. You're not sleeping, you're hardly eating, and when you look at me, I feel like you're a thousand miles away." Her voice trembled with emotion, each word saturated with care.

"It's like she's still calling out for help, Lisa," Oliver murmured, his voice thick with sorrow. "And I wasn't there for her."

"Oliver, love, we're here now, your family—me, Ethan, Abigail, Julia, and Daniel. We need you here with us."

Lisa reached out, laying a hand on his shoulder, feeling the tension coiled within his muscles. "Your sister would have wanted that too, wouldn't she?"

His body seemed to sag under the weight of her touch, a silent admission of his inner turmoil. The mask of determination slipped for a moment, revealing the raw anguish beneath. Oliver tilted his head back, finally meeting Lisa's gaze, the torment in his own eyes mirrored by the pain in hers.

"Promise me you'll come to bed soon?" she asked softly, her plea a lighthouse beckoning him back from the stormy sea of his obsession.

Oliver nodded, a mute vow to try, even as the relentless tide of unanswered questions pulled at him. They both knew the gravity of the situation—that their small town idyll was fraying at the edges, a thriller playing out in real life, with the stakes being their family's very heart.

With a final squeeze of his shoulder, Lisa retreated, her silhouette fading into the hallway, leaving Oliver to his vigil. The photographs and memorabilia whispered secrets just beyond his grasp.

A week later, the clock ticked past midnight in the dimly lit study. Shadows danced across the walls as the flickering flame of a lone lamp illuminated Oliver's furrowed brow. He shuffled through the scattered memorabilia with fervent intensity, each photograph a puzzle piece that refused to fit. The air was thick with the musty scent of old paper and the sharp tang of whiskey that clung to his breath.

"Oliver," Lisa's voice sliced through the silence like the peal of church bells on a quiet Sunday morning, startling him. She stood at the doorway, her silhouette framed by the soft yellow light from the hall, watching him with an ache in her hazel eyes.

"Lisa, I can't stop now. There's something here—I can feel it." Oliver's words were steel wrapped in velvet, his resolve unyielding despite the late hour.

"Darling, you've been at this for weeks. It's consuming you." Her approach was cautious, the floorboards creaking underfoot as she entered the room. "And the drinking—it's not helping. It's just—" Lisa stopped short, catching herself before saying too much.

"Not helping? You think I don't know that?" His voice cracked, a hairline fracture in his otherwise sturdy demeanor. "But this pain inside me, it drowns me without the booze. I need to numb it to keep going, to find closure."

"Oliver, please." The plea was raw, her own pain surfacing. "Think about Ethan, Abigail, Julia… Daniel. They're seeing you like this, broken, always with a bottle in your hand. We can't let that be their memory of their father."

He slammed his palm against the desk, the sound echoing, a punctuation mark to his frustration. "They need to remember me as someone who didn't give up on family! Someone who sought the truth, no matter the cost."

"Is the truth worth more than your health? Our children's happiness? Your life with me?" Lisa's voice trembled, but her conviction was steadfast.

"Without the truth, none of it means anything!" Oliver roared, his face a mask of anguish. "Can't you see that?"

"Oliver, look at me." Her command was gentle but firm. She took his hands in hers, the calluses of his woodworker's touch familiar and comforting. "You're not alone in this. But we need you whole, not shattered and lost to these shadows. Let's find help together."

He looked down at their entwined fingers, a lifeline amidst the storm of his grief. In that instant, the scales tipped—the weight of his sorrow pitted against the unwavering strength of her love. Oliver was a man adrift, but even now, he could sense the pull of the safe harbor she offered.

Her heart pounded with fear and hope as she held his gaze, searching for a sign of the man she loved within the tempest. Would he choose the warmth of her embrace or the cold comfort of his solitary quest?

"Okay, Lisa. Okay." His voice was barely above a whisper, a surrender to the concern glinting in her eyes. It was a start, a tiny crack in the armor he had built around himself these past weeks. But it didn’t last long.

---