Page 22 of The One that Got Away

"Sometimes, I'm scared that love isn't enough," Oliver's voice cracked, exposing a vulnerability she'd rarely seen. "Especially when I'm terrified of losing everything that matters most."

"Me too," Lisa confessed, allowing her walls to crumble. "I'm petrified. But perhaps it's that very fear that proves just how much this—how much you mean to me."

Their eyes locked, two souls stripped bare by the intensity of their own emotions… the future uncertain, yet their connection undeniable.

The wind picked up, whipping around them as if the earth itself could sense the turmoil brewing in their hearts. Lisa reached out, her fingers brushing against Oliver's, a silent plea for understanding amidst the chaos of their fears. He looked at her, his eyes a tempest of emotion, and let their hands intertwine. The simple touch was a reminder of their bond, a lifeline as the world threatened to pull them under.

"Ollie," she said, her voice laced with the warmth that had always drawn him to her, "I don't have all the answers. But I know that every moment without you would be like a day without sun."

His thumb caressed her knuckles tenderly, and for a fleeting second, it seemed as though they were back in the safe haven of their love, protected from the storm that raged around them. But the specter of their argument lingered, an unspoken shadow that refused to be ignored.

"Lisa, I—" Oliver started, the conflict clear in his furrowed brow. He paused, struggling to find the words that could bridge the chasm that had opened between them.

"Tell me," she urged, stepping closer, desperate to reclaim the unity they once took for granted.

He exhaled sharply, his chest rising and falling with the weight of his confession. "I miss the sea, the freedom… I feel trapped, not by you, but by this life we're trying to build. It's like I'm gasping for air."

Her heart clenched at his admission, the raw honesty of it cutting deeper than any fight they'd ever had. She lifted her hand to his face, tracing the line of his jaw with a tenderness that belied her inner turmoil. "We'll find our way back to the surface," she murmured, "together."

Oliver leaned into her touch, a small, vulnerable gesture that spoke volumes. They stood there, locked in a moment of connection, but the resolution they both sought remained elusive, hovering just beyond their grasp.

"Can we?" His question hung in the air, heavy with doubt.

"Can we what?" Her voice was steady, but her pulse raced with anxiety.

"Survive this? Be the couple who makes it through the storm?"

A gust of wind tugged at Lisa's hair, and she shivered, not from the cold but from the fear of what his question implied. She wanted to scream “yes” to banish the uncertainty that clouded his eyes, but the words caught in her throat, suffocated by the reality of their struggles.

Before she could respond, the sky erupted, a sudden clap of thunder rolling overhead like an omen. Rain began to fall, light at first, then quickly growing into a deluge that soaked them and chilled them to the bone.

"Let's go inside," Oliver said, his voice barely audible over the storm's roar.

They moved together, seeking shelter from the rain, but the true storm—the one raging within them—remained unsheltered, its end as unpredictable as the path of lightning across the night sky.

As they crossed the threshold of their home, Lisa turned to Oliver, her eyes searching his for something—anything—that might hint at their future. She found nothing to calm her anxiety. Oliver’s eyes were cold and distant like his heart had become.

Chapter Eight

Ava’s silhouette cut a sharp contrast against the fluttering curtains of the living room window, her posture an unyielding pillar amidst the sea of tension that flooded the small space. She and Daniel came over the next day while Lisa went for a walk with Julia in the stroller, and Marianne took care of the café.

The sight of her took Oliver’s breath away. She was still so incredibly beautiful it seemed impossible.

The sun draped her in its fiery glow, igniting the steely resolve in her gaze as she turned to face the door. With each step Oliver took across the threshold, his heart was beating a frantic rhythm against his chest, a symphony of anticipation for the confrontation he knew was inevitable.

"Oliver," Ava's voice quivered, betraying the storm of emotions brewing beneath her composed exterior. Though laced with anger, her words carried the tremble of vulnerability as they rose and fell in the hushed room. "I can't—I won’t live like this anymore. I know I said I didn’t come to cause trouble. And I truly didn’t. But my feelings for you… they’re still there. I want to be with you. I know I’m being selfish, but I can’t help it. I want you back in my life and in Daniel’s. Can’t you see? When we’re together, it all makes sense. The way Daniel looks at you, the warmth between us, the attraction. We’re a family. You have to make a choice."

She stood rooted, arms at her sides, her knuckles whitening as she fought to keep them from shaking. The air seemed to still around them, thick with the weight of her ultimatum.

"You can't ask me to just—" Oliver began, his voice trailing off as he looked at Ava. He saw not only the woman before him but also the echo of their shared past, a ghostly presence woven into the fabric of the moment. He swallowed hard, his Adam's apple bobbing with the effort to articulate feelings that had become shards of glass in his throat.

"Choose, Oliver!" Ava insisted, her plea slicing through the quietude and reverberating off the walls. Her eyes, those piercing orbs that once held nothing but adoration for him, now blazed with the fire of betrayal and hurt. They were the same eyes that watched over Daniel as he grew, had seen too much, and had forgiven even more.

Oliver felt the pull of his old life, the salt and spray of the ocean that coursed through his veins, the pull of the new one, the warmth of Lisa's smile, and the sound of her children's laughter. And Julia. Sweet little, innocent baby Julia. The room spun ever so slightly as he struggled under the gravity of Ava's demand, the air around him charged with the raw intensity of a love that refused to be ignored and another that refused to be cast aside.

The house's very foundation seemed to hold its breath, awaiting the shattering or mending of hearts. Oliver’s hands hovered, uncertain whether to reach out or withdraw, as he teetered on the precipice of a decision that would define the rest of their lives—all of their lives.

Oliver's gaze flicked from the tempest in Ava's steely blues to the bright sun outside the windows. The unspoken words hung heavy, a thick fog around his thoughts as he sought a lifeline in the turbulent sea of their emotions. His lips parted, but hesitation clung to his tongue like a stubborn barnacle.

---