Page 13 of The One that Got Away

"Then what are you saying, Lisa?" Oliver's temper flared, mirroring her own. "That we just give up?"

"Of course not!" The words erupted from her, charged with all the love and determination she held for her family. "But we need to be realistic about?—"

A sharp cry pierced through their argument, Julia's wails sounding from the nursery. Lisa stood abruptly, the maternal instinct trumping all else. As she hurried to comfort her baby, the tension with Oliver remained unresolved, a heavy fog settling over the house.

Later that night, after Julia had been soothed back to sleep with whispered lullabies and tender caresses, Lisa found herself alone in the small office downstairs. The day's receipts lay uncounted, abandoned in favor of staring blankly at the moonlit patterns dancing on the wall. Exhaustion tugged at the edges of her consciousness, but her mind refused to still, replaying the argument, the fears, and the unspoken words.

Above her, in the bedroom, Oliver lay in bed alone. His thoughts churned like storm-tossed waters, filled with love for Lisa and the life they had started to build, yet tormented by the unforeseen riptides of Ava's return. For many years, he had wished—and prayed—she would return to him. And now, she had. His feelings for her were still there, undeniably. But he also loved Lisa, and especially the family they had built. But today, when Ava had taken his hand in hers while watching Daniel on the playground, he had felt a surge of emotions rush through him. All the old feelings that had been lurking beneath the surface came back. He still loved her. He had to admit to it. But was it enough to want to upend his life? His family?

He closed his eyes, willing sleep to come, but found himself adrift in the uncertainty of their future.

As the clock ticked steadily onward, marking the passage of time in the silent house, Lisa and Oliver each faced their own restless battles. Despite the distance that had crept into their bed, they shared a common hope—a guiding light in the darkness—that somehow, they would find a way to navigate through this… together.

Lisa rose from the creaky chair in her office, the moonlight casting a silver sheen on her wavy brown hair. She wrapped her cardigan tighter around her slender frame, feeling the cool night air that seeped through the old window frames. Moving silently across the room, she stood for a moment at the threshold of the sleeping house, her eyes tracing the familiar contours of the life she had built, piece by painstaking piece.

There was a quiet strength in the stillness, a silent witness to the fortitude that pulsed within her veins. The trials that had once seemed insurmountable now formed the bedrock of her resilience. Lisa breathed deeply, finding solace in the steady rhythm of her own heartbeat.

"Tomorrow is another day with fresh new beginnings," she whispered into the darkness, a vow forming with each breath. Her love for Ethan, Abigail, and little Julia was an unbreakable chain. She would not let this new tempest—the whispers, the past reemerging with Ava's return—shatter their world.

Turning away from the door, Lisa tiptoed back to her desk, running her fingers over the woodwork. It was more than just furniture; it was Oliver's craftsmanship, his passion carved into every groove and grain. The same hands that crafted such beauty held hers through every hardship.

"Oliver," she said softly to herself, "we'll weather this too."

She glanced out the window once more, where the stars twinkled like distant lighthouses guiding weary travelers home. They beckoned her to believe in the dawn of a new day, one that promised the chance for clarity and conversations steeped in understanding rather than anger.

With that tender hope cradling her heart, Lisa allowed the fatigue of the day to guide her body toward rest. She slipped beneath the covers of their bed without waking Oliver, feeling the linen cool against her skin.

As sleep finally claimed her, the edges of her thoughts softened, blurring into dreams. Dreams where the challenges they faced were but shadows, dissolving in the light of a steadfast resolve. Dreams of tomorrow, where the intricate dance of their lives continued, each step a testament to their shared journey and their shared love.

Chapter Six

Lisa's hands trembled slightly as she placed the "Closed" sign on the door of the cozy yet usually bustling cafe. The last customer had left, leaving behind a silence that seemed to amplify the cacophony of her thoughts. With her back pressed against the cool glass of the door, she closed her eyes and inhaled deeply, trying to steady the rapid beating of her heart.

The day's challenges weighed heavily upon her—unpaid bills, an unexpected shortage of coffee beans, a broken espresso machine—all piling atop the personal struggles that gnawed at her peace of mind. Her hair, usually neatly pinned up while working, cascaded in disheveled locks around her face as if mirroring the chaos within.

In this quiet moment, she allowed herself to feel it all—the fear, the exhaustion, the relentless pressure of being everything to everyone. A single tear escaped the corner of her eye, tracing a warm path down her cheek, but she quickly wiped it away with a determination born from years of overcoming adversities that would have shattered someone less resilient.

Outside, the quaint streets of the small town were bathed in the soft glow of the afternoon sun, casting long shadows that danced with the gentle breeze. Lyle Cooper, returning from his daily walk, noticed the subtle shift in Lisa's posture through the cafe window. His brow furrowed with concern for his neighbor, whom he had come to admire for her tenacity and warmth.

He approached the entrance, his footsteps soundless against the cobblestone path. Lyle paused for a fraction of a second, debating the intrusion, but his kind nature overruled any hesitation. He tapped lightly on the door, his grey-blue eyes filled with empathy, before walking in.

"Lisa?" Lyle's voice was a soothing balm, his presence an anchor in the storm threatening to sweep her away. “Are you okay?”

She opened her eyes, the sight of him offering a flicker of solace. Even in distress, she couldn't help but notice the genuine worry etched in the lines of his face—a face that had offered her countless smiles and words of wisdom.

"Hey, Lyle," she managed, her voice steadier than she felt. "I’m fine. I just needed a minute."

"Everyone needs a minute sometimes," Lyle said, his tone light yet laden with meaning. "Mind if I join you for yours?"

As he waited for her response, there was an electric charge in the air—and they both felt it.

“No, not at all. Do you want a cup of coffee?”

Lisa exhaled a shaky breath, her fingers absently tracing the rim of her coffee mug. Lyle pulled up a chair, his presence a quiet force in the whirlwind of Lisa's world. She looked into his eyes, finding an unexpected harbor there.

"I don't even know where to start," she confessed, the words tumbling out like the first drops before a storm. "The cafe, the woodwork shop, my kids… I can handle those, barely. But Ava—her being here—it's like juggling knives. And I'm just waiting to drop one."

"Life has a way of throwing more at us than we think we can handle," Lyle said, leaning forward, elbows resting on the table. His voice was steady, a counterpoint to the tremble in hers. "But you're not just anyone, Lisa. You're the woman who rebuilt her life from scratch, who protects her family like a lioness. You've got grit and heart, and you've turned this place," he gestured to the cozy cafe, "into a second home for half the town."

---