Page 32 of The Keeper

Seth arched a brow. “What are you up to?”

Rueben released his tortured lip to heave a sigh. “I had an idea, but I think it might not be the right time.”

“Tell me and let me decide for myself.”

“You have a lot on your mind.”

“I do.” There was no point in denying it. Seth slid his fist up and down Rueben’s cock again in a solitary, lazy stroke. “Getting your dick inside my mouth is near the top of priorities.”

The noise that escaped Rueben’s gifted lips started as a chuckle and ended in a moan when Seth added a second stroke. “But you have that town hall meeting tonight, and I—”

Seth cut him off with a kiss. The face-off against Martindale was the last thing he wanted to think about, let alone talk about, during his stolen time with Rueben. He slid his other hand down the back of Rueben’s jeans and trailed teasing digits between firm cheeks until his fingertips brushed up against something hard. Seth’s lips curved into a smile. “Found your surprise.” He traced the crinkled entrance at the base of the plug. “You make it so damn hard to take my time and love you slowly.”

Rueben groaned and swayed into his chest, then lifted his hands and went to work on the buttons on Seth’s shirt. “That’s not my only surprise.”

“But wait, there’s more?” Seth asked. His voice was too husky and lust-drunk to sound like an infomercial, but the joke still landed. Seth kissed Rueben’s smiling lips. “I don’t need more. Just you.”

Rueben’s hands stilled, and he raised his head to meet Seth’s gaze. He swallowed audibly before swiping his tongue over his bottom lip. Seth wanted to ease his nerves by any means necessary, but it was obvious this moment was important to Rueben, so he waited patiently. His reward would be something he never would’ve predicted when they agreed to meet at the cabin again. “Giving myself to you is exactly what I’m trying to do, but I’m probably fucking it up.” Rueben reached behind him and pulled out a folded piece of paper from his back pocket.

Seth’s heart hammered in his chest, and awareness cut through his fog of lust as he read down the list of test results. Rueben was offering all of himself without limitations and barriers. “Are you serious?”

Rueben nodded. “But we don’t…if you don’t…”

Seth gripped Rueben’s ass hard and held him flush against his throbbing body. “Oh, I want. So fucking much.” The words came out in a snarled growl that matched the possessiveness clawing at his guts. “I also got tested a few months ago, and you’re the only one I’ve been with since last fall. I don’t have documentation with me, but—”

Rueben’s lips cut him off as the piece of paper fell to the floor. Seth started backing him up through the cabin. There were a few different surfaces in the living room they could’ve used, but he wanted to lay Rueben out on the big bed. They continued to kiss as they undressed one another in the cramped quarters. Seth didn’t immediately remove the plug and thrust home; he took his time worshipping Rueben’s body to show how much he cherished his gift. Seth used his broad shoulders to spread Rueben’s thighs apart and made himself comfortable there. He nuzzled the sensitive skin he wanted to mark while pushing on the base of the butt plug. Seth sucked the delicate flesh between his lips, and Rueben made a keening sound, arching his back and digging his heels into the mattress. Seth gazed up the golden expanse of skin, committing Rueben’s flushed cheeks, parted lips, and shimmering eyes to memory. Another nudge made Rueben’s dick jerk, and Seth knew he could make him come just from this. Maybe someday, but he wanted more from Reuben right then.

Seth licked, sucked, and nipped the spot just to the right of Rueben’s throbbing dick until he’d sufficiently left his mark. Then he took Rueben’s erection into his mouth, not stopping until his nose touched bare skin at the base of Rueben’s cock. The butt plug bounced every time Rueben’s pucker flexed, and salty precum splashed onto his tongue. Rueben growled lustily and fisted his hands in Seth’s hair, snapping his hips up to fuck Seth’s eager mouth. His scalp stung, his eyes watered, and his lungs burned, but Seth was too concerned about pleasuring Rueben to worry about little things like baldness or breathing.

“Pull off.” Rueben used his grip to ensure Seth’s capitulation. “I want to come with your cock inside me, then I want you to pump me full.”

Seth was already revved and ready, but Rueben’s words were almost enough to push him over the edge without additional stimulation. This was one load he didn’t want to waste, so he eased back onto his haunches so he could watch the pretty pucker relinquish the plug. Seth pushed Rueben’s legs toward his chest to give himself unrestricted access and view. The plug was a deep purple, and when Seth eased it free, he noticed it was shaped like an eggplant. He was tempted to push that curved tip back inside Rueben to torment his stimulated prostate some more, but the quivering, relaxed hole was too tempting to ignore, and his aching dick was too eager to come.

Seth paused long enough to slick a thin layer of lube on his dick before lining up to Rueben’s hole. His first thought was to plow straight to the heart of him, but the little minx arrived with plans to drive Seth wild, and he wanted to return the favor. He slid the fat head of his cock inside the tight ring of muscles and fought his instincts to thrust in balls deep. Seth used his slicked hand to work Rueben’s drooling cock.

“Fuck me.”

“I’ll get around to it,” Seth replied as if his body wasn’t demanding release too.

Rueben unfolded his legs to rest his heels on Seth’s shoulders in a fluid motion, then used the leverage to impale himself on Seth’s cock. “Come down here and fuck me properly, you sexy bastard.”

Seth lowered his body onto Rueben, who hooked his knees over Seth’s shoulders to hold on for dear life while taking the pounding his words and actions begged for. “Like this?”

Rueben’s brown eyes lost focus, but his mouth was still sharp and full of sass. “It’s pretty good.”

Seth dug his knees into the mattress and pegged that prostate until Rueben’s teeth rattled. His tormentor’s breath caught in his throat, and his asshole put Seth’s dick in a chokehold while Reuben came hard enough to paint his chin and neck with his spunk. The sexy sight obliterated Seth’s control, and he relaxed into the orgasm clawing at his guts. He came hard enough to see black dots as Rueben’s tight channel milked him dry. Seth collapsed fully on top of him, rutting and glorying in the feel of his slick seed in Rueben’s tight passage. His hips eventually stilled, and Seth finally lifted his head.

“When you spot me in the crowd tonight, you’ll know I’ve got part of you inside me.”

Seth’s breath hitched, and his nostrils flared. The sentiment was both sweet and sexy and deserved a response of equal value. Seth captured Rueben’s wrist and kissed his palm before settling his hand over Seth’s pounding heart. “That’s not the only thing of mine you’ve hijacked.”

Rueben gave him the most beautiful smile Seth had ever seen. “I’m not giving it back.”

Seth lowered his head to see if the grin tasted as good as it looked. Yep. “Good.”

And like the previous week, they performed minimal cleanup and twined around one another in a tangle of limbs in the center of the bed. Seth wouldn’t usually bring up touchy or heavy subjects at such a tender moment, but the full weight of what Rueben had said about the town hall meeting finally sank in.

“Are you really going to be there tonight?” The idea of seeing Rueben in the crowd should terrify him since Seth didn’t trust himself not to give away his feelings in a single glance. But the notion comforted him instead, especially since his parents had left for a month-long Alaskan cruise to celebrate their anniversary. Seth could use as many people in his corner as he could get.

---