Page 35 of Stay

“What’s so funny, Angel?”

“I’m just thinking how you always bragged about your magic fingers.” I wink. “Gotta say, your magic powers have leveled up.”

“That’s not all that’s leveled up.” He reaches under his bed to pull out a box. “Not to be presumptuous but I went ahead and got us some fun toys.”

Oh my God. He went all out. But one thing in the box isn’t new, and it’s what makes me wet most.

I pull out the paddle that’s got Daddy’s Angel engraved in it. “You kept this?”

“Of course.”

He says it like he knew I’d come back to him one day and we’d need it.

I dig through the box and pluck out a blindfold. I twirl it playfully around my finger and pull out a ball gag. “Is this for me or you?”

“Whoever wants it more.”

I point out a stainless-steel butt plug. “What about that?”

“All you, Angel.” Cole maneuvers me onto his lap and guides my head down to the mattress so I’m over his knee. “Cover your eyes for Daddy.”

My heart leaps into my throat. Slipping the black satin blindfold on, I’m thrown back to the first time we did this. It was exciting and scary. Addictive.

Cole’s big hand runs along my ass and my pussy clenches.

Thwack!

Pain radiates out from my butt cheek.

Thwack!

I can barely breathe.

“How’s that feel?”

“G-g-good.”

“Good what?” Thwack!

“Good, Daddy.” The burn feels amazing, but the next hit makes me yip.

“My Angel’s ass is redder than a cherry.” He rubs his hand over my backside. “Just how I like it.” He dips his hand between my thighs. “Fucking soaked.” He shoves his finger in my pussy, twisting it until I moan. I have no clue what he’s hitting in there, but it’s phenomenal. “Spread your ass for me.”

Precariously balanced on his lap, I reach back and do as he says.

“That’s my good girl.” He spits on my tight hole and circles his finger around it. I melt into his lap. “So fucking tight everywhere,” he groans, sinking his finger in my ass. “What a needy little thing you are. No one’s fucked these holes in so long.”

I’m too stupefied to talk.

“You want Daddy to fill them, don’t you?”

I nod.

Thwack! He spanks me with his hand and grabs my ass cheek hard, jiggling it. “Use your words.”

“Y-yes.” I swallow the saliva building in my mouth. “Please, Daddy.”

Cole pulls out and lowers me onto the floor. “Stay on your knees.” I hear him walk away and water runs in another room. Then I hear him go further away, like he’s in the kitchen or something. I don’t have a clue. I’ll just wait here, blindfolded, like his good girl, until he comes back.

---