Page 123 of Ride a Cowboy

Sadie felt foolish for ever thinking she wasn’t a part of this. “I just need one more thing.”

Joel groaned when she grabbed the remote control for the plug. “I was hoping you’d forget about that. This isn’t going to last long as it is. You turn that thing on…”

Sadie laughed. “We’ll just have to keep practicing this way until we build up our stamina.”

“Deal,” Oakley said hastily. “Now get under me, Sade. I need to be inside you.”

She crawled under Oakley, sighing when the head of his cock brushed against her clit. It would take precious little to set her off like a bottle rocket.

Oakley kissed her as she settled beneath him, his tongue stroking hers hungrily. “God, I missed you.”

Feeling guilty for being too stupid to live and rejecting their affections, she kissed him back and offered him the same vow he and Joel gave her on the porch. The one that even now was resonating in her heart. “Never again. I’ll never be so stupid again.”

“You going to tell us what changed your mind?” he asked.

She nodded.

“Later.” Joel’s voice had taken on an almost pained tone that had her laughing again. She’d never been this downright giddy before. “She can tell us later.”

Oakley didn’t bother to disagree. Instead, he grasped his cock and guided it into Sadie. She gasped as he continued to push in, not stopping until he was completely lodged within her. Then, he paused.

She started to give him hell for stopping, for teasing her, but Joel wasn’t wasting any time. She heard the crinkle of the condom wrapper, then heard Oakley hiss.

Joel tried to go slow, tried to wrap his head around what was happening. There were too many good things, too many amazing sensations overwhelming him. Oakley pressed back against his cock as Joel pushed into him. He was doing it. Making love to Oakley. God. And Sadie.

He’d never once—in all his life—considered having sex with another man. However, he had been able to think of little else since that Truth or Dare game. Then, like now, it was Sadie who’d given him the push he’d needed to take this chance.

Joel tightened his grip on Oakley’s hips. He hadn’t been joking when he said this wouldn’t take long. Having sex with a man was so different from being with a woman. Joel suddenly understood Oakley’s desire for both sexes.

Oakley groaned once he was fully lodged. Joel couldn’t resist making the journey again, so he withdrew instantly. As he moved out, Oakley moved into Sadie. Within a half-dozen thrusts, they had found a rhythm that had each of them gasping, clenching and begging for more.

Joel had anticipated an easier ride for their first time, but none of them ever seemed content to take the path of least resistance. Each thrust grew harder and the pace increased. Joel wondered how in the fuck Oakley was hanging in there and for a moment, he considered what it must feel like to be doubly penetrated.

Sadie reminded him.

He’d forgotten about the vibrating plug she’d placed in his ass. She hadn’t. He jerked when the damn thing started moving and his balls filled. He had foolishly thought he would be able to outlast them.

Sadie seemed determined to win that race as the vibrations increased.

“Fuck me,” Joel muttered when the plug hit top speed, beating a tango in his ass that had him rutting like a wild beast. He pounded harder in Oakley’s ass, driving his lover deeper into Sadie.

Oakley was the first to plummet as he came loudly, cursing fluently. “Jesus mother-fucking Christ. Son of a goddamn bitch.”

Sadie followed, her nails scratching deeply into Oakley’s shoulders. His friend didn’t appear to feel any pain from her scoring.

That was Joel’s last cognizant thought before his climax struck. For one brief, astounding moment, the world went black. And then he tumbled, crash-landing into a heap of sweaty, trembling bodies gasping for breath.

“Holy shit.”

He chuckled at Sadie’s perfect summation of what had just happened. They slowly untangled body parts and, in the end, Joel found himself sandwiched between Oakley and Sadie. He reached for Sadie’s hand to tug the remote control from her clenched fist. Joel turned it off as Sadie giggled and said, “Sorry.”

“Someone is going to have to get this damn thing out of me,” he said, which prompted laughter from both sides of him.

“You aren’t fooling anybody, Joel. Why don’t you just go ahead and admit you like having your ass filled?”

Joel turned to give Oakley a warning glance. “Don’t start getting any ideas.” Then, he grinned, deciding he was an idiot to deny the truth. “Yet.”

Then he sat up and made his way to the bathroom to dispose of the condom. He was surprised to find Sadie and Oakley right on his heels.

---