Page 156 of The Pact

My hands cup her as I kiss down her neck and across her shoulder. Her scent is intoxicating, both the vanilla mixed with the perfume Damian bought her.

Glancing at Cole, I give him a look that tells him exactly what we’re going to do. He nods in agreement and starts undoing his pants. I do the same. Thea doesn’t need any direction from us. She pulls her shorts off.

“Damn, baby.” My hands run over her round ass, making my cock desperate for her attention.

Cole steps up to her, taking the lead. I watch as he kisses Thea, his hand dipping between her legs. Her moans as he plays with her pussy have me stroking myself. We’ve only done this once before, so it’ll take some maneuvering to get it right. And hopefully Thea’s up for what we have in mind.

Thea steps away from Cole, dropping to her knees between us. Oh, fuck…is she—She wraps her mouth around Cole, pushing him all the way to the end of her throat before pulling away and coming to me. She slides my cock between her full pink lips while her hand strokes Cole. “Christ, Thea,” I moan out. It should be illegal for anyone to be this good at what she’s doing.

I hate to do it, but if she keeps this up, I’m going to come much sooner than I’d like. So I pull away from her mouth, grab her arm and force her to stand.

Cole drags her close to him, then hooks an arm beneath her knee, lifting it to give us both better access to her. He needs to go first. I’m not even sure if she’ll be okay with what I want to do. We’ll have to ease her in. I watch as my brother guides his stiff cock to her entrance and pushes inside of her.

“Oh, Cole,” Thea whimpers as he thrusts in gently. “Harder, please,” she begs. I chuckle at her impatience. She’s going to have to wait a bit longer for that.

I trail my fingers over her ass, wondering if she’s ever been fucked like that before or if I’ll be the first. I’m not sure which I’d prefer—each has their perks. Either way, I’m going to need a shit ton of lube. Looking around, I try to get creative, not wanting to disappear downstairs and miss anything.

My gaze slides to the cabinet next to the stove. Maybe… I slip away from Cole and Thea to check. Opening it up, I spot what I was hoping for. Coconut oil. Grabbing it, I rejoin them. Slipping my fingers into the jar, I coat them generously before returning to Thea’s ass.

The wetness of the oil draws her attention to me as I slide my hand between her cheeks. “Sutton?”

Pulling her mouth to mine, I kiss her and press my fingers against her tight hole, making her gasp. “I want to fuck you here, baby. I want Cole and I to fuck you at the same time.” I watch her throat bob as she swallows and her eyes go wide. If she says no, that’s alright, however, I really hope she says yes.

“Okay…just go slow.”

I kiss her again and promise, “Of course. Tell me to stop if it’s too much.” She nods.

Circling her with my slick finger, I press into her until I slip inside. Thea’s breathing speeds up momentarily at the new sensation. “That’s it, baby. You’re doing so good. How does it feel?” I ask as I gently move my finger in and out of her.

Her head falls back onto my shoulder. “There’s a lot of pressure…but it’s good,” she pants out.

Cole thrusts into her hard, making her bite her lip in pleasure. I wait for him to pull out before slipping a second finger into her ass. Cole slams into her, distracting her from any discomfort I might be causing by stretching her out. I let him fuck her for a minute before I fuck her with my fingers.

It’s not long before she’s moaning loudly and arching her ass into me, wanting more. I can’t wait anymore. I pull out of her, making her whimper in disappointment. I’m quick to scoop out a handful of the oil and slather my dick.

Spreading her cheeks, I guide myself into her, slowly pushing the tip of myself in. Thea’s entire body tenses, although Cole handles her perfectly.

“Hey.” He pulls her attention back to him. “Take a deep breath. Relax your body. It’ll help.” She does as he says and I’m able to slip in a little farther. Christ, she’s so fucking tight. “Breath. Relax. Breath.” Cole walks her through it until I’m all the way in. I give her a few minutes to get used to the stretch.

My fingers trace over her back, up her neck, and into her dark waves. I grip her gently, tilting her neck to kiss it. With each one, I feel the tenseness leave her body. Cole does too because he resumes thrusting into her.

I can feel him as he moves in and out. I’d be lying if I said it didn’t feel so fucking amazing. After a few minutes, I can’t help it—I have to fuck her, too.

“Oh God. Oh God,” Thea cries out.

“We can stop if you want us to, baby.” I grate out. I don’t want to stop. It feels too damn good. But I will if she needs us to.

She glances back at me. “You better not,” Thea warns.

That’s all it takes for Cole and I to find the perfect rhythm, pumping in and out of her, the feel of our cocks nearly touching intensifying everything. “Are you close?” I whisper in her ear. I can’t hold off much longer, yet I need her to come first.

Thea doesn’t answer with a yes or no. Instead, her whole body shudders and she’s screaming out as her release slams into her. It’s enough to make me go next as she clenches around me. My hands grip her hips as I bury and spill myself deep inside of her.

Cole keeps thrusting. The sensation has both Thea and I overloaded with sensitivity, holding on for dear life until he finally finds his own release.

We’re all breathless and spent, standing in the kitchen, hardly able to move.

“I love you,” Thea pants out.

---