"You feel so perfect," I rasp into her hair, forcing myself to keep my motions relaxed. "So tight and wet around me. So sexy, baby."
A sigh rumbles through her, shaking her breasts. "I know you're being gentle and holding back, and I appreciate it. But you can…" She flutters her eyelashes. "You know. Let go a little bit."
My groan is nearly a roar as I scoop an arm under her back, angling her so I can plunge faster, deeper. She urges me on, flexing her thighs, her fingernails pin-pricking against the back of my shoulders.
I worry that I'm being way too rough for this sweet girl's first time. But her pussy welcomes me deep, slick and swollen with need. Her tight pink nipples stroke against my chest, thighs twitching as I find a rhythm that satisfies us both. "Is this what you need, baby?"
"Yes." Her voice is muffled, as if she's afraid to open her lips.
"Trying not to squeal too loud?"
"Yeah."
Pulling all the way out, I slide the tip of my shaft up and down her clit until she squirms restlessly under me. "But what if I want to hear you let it all out?" Burying myself fully inside her, her head falls back with a long, loud moan as her shoulders thrash, hips shaking. "That's it, my baby. All of me. All of you."
Her lips fall open with a shuddering breath as I'm struck again by how beautiful this girl is.
"Tell me you're mine." I don't know where the command comes from, but it's heartfelt. I reach my thumb down to her clit, massaging gently as I feel her thighs tighten. "Tell me." My voice drops to a harsh whisper as our eyes lock. She's so close, her breaths at a fever pitch as the bed rocks under us.
"I'm…yours."
My heart surges, and I'm unable to stop myself from saying it any longer.
"I love you, Kallie. I know you're going to need more time and that's fine and you don't need to say it back, but I need you to know that I love you."
Her huge blue eyes stare into mine as we cling to each other, our raspy breath filling the inch between us as we reach the edge at the same time.
"Moore…" My name barely escapes out of her lips. Then she screams, the climax flooding her body, her lips pressed against my chest.
I hold her and watch her contort in bliss, dazzled by her beauty as she shakes through her climax.
Kissing her to swallow the noises, I growl like an animal, pounding hard and fast as I explode inside her, coming so hard I nearly black out for a split second from the feeling of her hot pussy squeezing me tightly. Panting, I cradle her tenderly, holding her close as we stare at each other in wonder.
Her fingertips drag down my chest, then she gasps. "Oh my God! I bit you. I'm so sorry."
Craning my neck downward, there's indeed a little red smudge over my heart. Laughing, I roll us so that we're on our sides again. "I'm going to wear that mark with pride. Show the guys that my little sex kitten is totally out of control."
She looks at me in alarm. "You wouldn't dare."
"No, of course I wouldn't." I pull the blankets over us as she stretches and shivers a bit. "Cold?"
"No." Her perfect lips stretch into a saucy smile. "But I think my body is confused about what just happened." She leans in to kiss my cheek. "It was amazing, though. Be right back."
Kallie slips into the bathroom for a moment, so I get up to blow out the candles and put another log on the fire.
She comes back to bed and curls right into my arms. "We fit together pretty well, don't we?" I ask, stroking her shoulder and arm as our feet brush together.
"Yeah. We do." She looks at me carefully, and I can almost hear her worrying about everything. "Moore, I?—"
I place a finger over her lips. "It's far too late for big conversations. You need sleep, my beautiful baby."
She sighs with relief. "Okay. Sweet dreams."
I expect a light good night kiss. Instead, she cups my face in both her hands, giving me a long, slow, sensual kiss that feels like it goes on forever. Once we're breathless, I pull back, dazed. "I'm not complaining, but what was that for?"
Kallie smiles. "You said I couldn't talk. So you got that instead. Good night."
Just when I thought the best night of my life couldn't get any better, I think Kallie just tried to tell me that she loves me too.